The Doomed Cruise - Game [OVER AND OUT ]

[Defiant_Blob]

Looks like we're going for a no lynch, but I'm still going to throw my vote in for Defiant. While there's nothing wrong with playing aggressive, so to speak, I don't like how he's doing it. He's voted without reason and then later backed out with poor excuses. I also feel he's tried to use his character as a guise to avoid some suspicion.

vote Defiant_Blob

FONT=courier new]VRISKA: I've explained all of my votes for the most part if I'm not mistaken.
VRISKA: I voted for Coolio to stir up discussion and see who would think what.
VRISKA: I voted for Omar to see who would 8e fine with voting for someone 8ecause they were away.
VRISKA: If you think I was actually trying to kill either you're sorely mistaken.
VRISKA: Had that 8een the case I would have fought for each vote much harder.
VRISKA: I'd like you and the others to provide a more logical and valid argument for voting me.
VRISKA: Especially anyone that didn't actually provide reasoning 8ut rather just said they agreed with others and just paraphrased to make them seem valid.
VRISKA: Also those who think it's a valid argument to just say "I think they're scummy 8ecause they're words seem scummy to me and I don't like it but I'm not going to provide actual reasoning or examples."[/FONT]

 

[Vino]

Looks like we're going for a no lynch, but I'm still going to throw my vote in for Defiant. While there's nothing wrong with playing aggressive, so to speak, I don't like how he's doing it. He's voted without reason and then later backed out with poor excuses. I also feel he's tried to use his character as a guise to avoid some suspicion.

vote Defiant_Blob

FONT=courier new]VRISKA: I've explained all of my votes for the most part if I'm not mistaken.
VRISKA: I voted for Coolio to stir up discussion and see who would think what.
VRISKA: I voted for Omar to see who would 8e fine with voting for someone 8ecause they were away.
VRISKA: If you think I was actually trying to kill either you're sorely mistaken.
VRISKA: Had that 8een the case I would have fought for each vote much harder.
VRISKA: I'd like you and the others to provide a more logical and valid argument for voting me.
VRISKA: Especially anyone that didn't actually provide reasoning 8ut rather just said they agreed with others and just paraphrased to make them seem valid.
VRISKA: Also those who think it's a valid argument to just say "I think they're scummy 8ecause they're words seem scummy to me and I don't like it but I'm not going to provide actual reasoning or examples."[/FONT]

THE BOuLDER is suspicious of the excuses you made for your votes. THE BOuLDER thinks you are making up excuses to justify your actual means of voting. THE BOuLDER thinks that you chose them because they were easy targets and you want people eliminated. THE BOuLDER however, does not think this means you are mafia. THE BOuLDER believes that you are just trying to rid the game of players very fast, and this is suspicious. THE BOuLDER now sets you as suspect number one. THE BOuLDER will now prepare his massive pecks and giant fists if he needs the introduce you to them.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

THE BOuLDER is suspicious of the excuses you made for your votes. THE BOuLDER thinks you are making up excuses to justify your actual means of voting. THE BOuLDER thinks that you chose them because they were easy targets and you want people eliminated. THE BOuLDER however, does not think this means you are mafia. THE BOuLDER believes that you are just trying to rid the game of players very fast, and this is suspicious. THE BOuLDER now sets you as suspect number one. THE BOuLDER will now prepare his massive pecks and giant fists if he needs the introduce you to them.

VRISKA: It hardly works to say as soon as I vote "I'm voting this guy 8ut not 8ecause I want to kill him I just want reactions so don't suspect me."
VRISKA: If I'd done that I wouldn't have gotten the reactions I wanted.

 

[Alisha]

One question BOuLDER:

You say you don't see Defiant as mafia, yet you also say he is suspect number one, and choosing easy targets. In my head (apolgies if wrong, i'm going right to sleep after this post), those sound like conflicting statements.

 

[cooliorules]

Defiant, just the way that you voted for me saying that you had much luck, and that all would follow, it just feels like you're being too aggressive for you to be town sided.
Yu then quickly invited, saying "I wanted to stir discussion"
That, surely, could have been done in a different way. Maybe saying something like "I suspect coolio, blah blah blah"
Then you voted for Omar, because he wasn't there. Wasn't saying much.
Then, once again, unbored to "stir discussion".
This, to me, seems shifty. I don't like it. That, my friend (I don't mean anything by this, I say it a lot at school and stuff), deems you the number 1 position on my suspicious list.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

Defiant, just the way that you voted for me saying that you had much luck, and that all would follow, it just feels like you're being too aggressive for you to be town sided.
Yu then quickly invited, saying "I wanted to stir discussion"
That, surely, could have been done in a different way. Maybe saying something like "I suspect coolio, blah blah blah"
Then you voted for Omar, because he wasn't there. Wasn't saying much.
Then, once again, unbored to "stir discussion".
This, to me, seems shifty. I don't like it. That, my friend (I don't mean anything by this, I say it a lot at school and stuff), deems you the number 1 position on my suspicious list.

VRISKA: Why would I give reasoning if I didn't want you dead? No one would take a fake suspicion seriously if I just said I was suspicious. Only when I vote they take it seriously. But I didn't actually try to coax other to follow through reasoning.
VRISKA: If I wanted you dead I could have tried to actually argue for it.
VRISKA: I didn't unvote for Omar to stir discussion.
VRISKA: I voted for him to see who might agree with the idea of killing those who are away.
VRISKA: I still deny your argument has validity.
VRISKA: You yourself say I only seem shifty and that you just don't like it.
VRISKA: You're going on gut feelings rather than logic to vote me out.

 

[Vino]

One question BOuLDER:

You say you don't see Defiant as mafia, yet you also say he is suspect number one, and choosing easy targets. In my head (apolgies if wrong, i'm going right to sleep after this post), those sound like conflicting statements.

THE BOuLDER has taken an advanced English class to write an easy-to-understand explanation (Totally not a copout to stop typing in third person)

Spoiler

In a nutshell, i suspect defient greatly as being either a mafia member, or perhaps a special role, however i don't want to take the chance of lynching just yet. His way of responding to the votes and the suspicion's being drawn is a lot more aggressive and defensive than the others we have called out. This may mean he is infact mafia, or it may just mean he is bad at wording his posts. I'm not ready to lynch him yet, however i still would like to keep an eye on him. -BOuLDER

THE BOuLDER has now forgotten all his English capabilities. THE BOuLDER will now throw pebbles off of the boat and act very philosophical. THE BOuLDER is now looking dramatically in the far distance while flexing.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

((Just a note that I'm roleplaying an already existing character with a very aggressive, manipulative, and confident personality. As such, I am basing my words and actions around how Vriska would act. If you want to view info on the personality I linked her Wiki page in my signature. I'm mostly saying this because people keep basing suspicions upon aspects of my roleplay.

I also want to note that I am playing this for fun. Meaning I am not playing super competitively and rather for the roleplay fun.))

 

[Vino]

THE BOuLDER thinks the people in this thread want to see his massive muscles. THE BOuLDER will now show a picture of his truly outrageous body.

Spoiler

THE BOuLDER also wants to add to his last post that in some forms of mafia, there is a role that wins if they are lynched. THE BOuLDER warn's the others of this sneaky little rat. THE BOuLDER doesn't like rats. THE BOuLDER likes weightlifting. THE BOuLDER will now begin lifting very heavy weights.

 

[myusername22]

*eman 22 resuym walks up to the boulder.*

Hey you seem pretty suspicious to me would you mind answering a few questions?*he asks*

1.who would win in a fight the boulder or a boulder?
2. Who would win in another fight you or lord gmk?
3. If your as strong as you say you are why haven't you killed the mafia yet.
4. How much wood would a wood chuck chuck if a wood chuck could chuck wood
5. Why did the chicken cross the road.
6. Do you have parents? What happened to them? Why did they name you boulder?

 

[Vino]

*eman 22 resuym walks up to the boulder.*

Hey you seem pretty suspicious to me would you mind answering a few questions?*he asks*

1.who would win in a fight the boulder or a boulder?
2. Who would win in another fight you or lord gmk?
3. If your as strong as you say you are why haven't you killed the mafia yet.
4. How much wood would a wood chuck chuck if a wood chuck could chuck wood
5. Why did the chicken cross the road.
6. Do you have parents? What happened to them? Why did they name you boulder?

THE BOuLDER answers all your questions with "YES"
THE BOuLDER will now go back to building orphanages for young children while playing them a sweet lullaby on his abb xylophone.

 

[GmK]

Voting deadline as explained earlier:
Wednesday 18th September, 9pm GMT ( http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=9 pm GMT in my timezone ).
The majority vote by then will be taken. Except of course if the voting reaches a result beforehand.


///VOTECOUNT///

Players needed to lynch: 16
Players needed to no-lynch: 15

No Lynch - 14 - digitalmez, shinyshark, grimmjowforever, K1ngHoward, infernofox, mariosatr, ansoro, kraby1, Prizyms, balloon98, HypeBurst, myusername22, storm886, Jivvi (NL-1)
K1ngHoward - 1 - MarsKid (L-15)
myusername22 - 2 - nottykitten, endersteve5 (L-14)
Nottykitten - 1- Vatumok (L-15)
Defiant_Blob - 4 - cooliorules, One One Two, Sploorky, Dessern5 (L-12)

Players not voting: Alpha102, Ooglie, 77_is_the_best, hihihilolHI, Old_Man_Oak_63, Omar_Sales, nitasu987, Defiant_Blob

 

[cooliorules]

It's not JUST your character, Defiant, but when I got voted, I didn't keep on going, it's only 4 votes, you're not going to be voted out. Your reaction see,s to be too far concerned for what a passenger or town sided role would be. I may be wrong, y may be town sided, and the fact that you won't let it drop, you won't give up, you just won't accept it.

From the seasons I've read, if someone is being accused and on the verge of lynching, or even just have a few votes, people don't react so.. Trying to think of he word...
React so.... Dramatically? Worried? Panicked? I can't think of the word that fits best there, so sorry if that doesn't make much sense.

(Sorry for late response, has a class switch into a class I can't go on my iPad x3)

 

[myusername22]

I think I should finally give my opinion on the entire defiant situation.

Yes he did raise quite a few red flags before but I think he was too obvious to be mafia seems Towny as far as I can see. May be someone to watch though.

Coolio, I think his reactions are justified yes he's obviously not being voted out this round but look at the people who are accusing him. On top of that they have pretty valid looking points on there side and the situation could easily turn on him if it weren't for the fact its day 0

 

[Mooglie]

I think I should finally give my opinion on the entire defiant situation.
Yes he did raise quite a few red flags before but I think he was too obvious to be mafia seems Towny as far as I can see. May be someone to watch though.

Just had some weird thoughts about Defiant go through my head:
His character looks evil and plays rather 'aggressively' but that in a lot of players heads means that that is good... But here's where the weird thought comes in: What if, as a rather good player of Mafia he knows how to know these things and predict what others will do/think (much like me in RAF in IRC Mafia) and is using this to advantage, knowing that people will trust him (I still do, like I said - weird thought) but that is ultimately a cover up for being eviiiiil, kinda like a double bluff. And there's my really weird theory that makes no sense because it also works if Defiant is a passenger but: The reason he took so long to confirm his role was because he was asking questions to the host about it and due to a timezone difference of some-sort the answers were delayed and therefore lead to Defiant to be the last person to confirm... Then there's the larger possibility he was just inactive or was asking whether is roleplay character would be allowed.

Like I said, weird thought, probably something not to be followed because I for some strange reason trust Defiant (even though that still is proving the first half of my thought Dx)

Read my posts D:<

 

[myusername22]

I think I should finally give my opinion on the entire defiant situation.
Yes he did raise quite a few red flags before but I think he was too obvious to be mafia seems Towny as far as I can see. May be someone to watch though.

Just had some weird thoughts about Defiant go through my head:
His character looks evil and plays rather 'aggressively' but that in a lot of players heads means that that is good... But here's where the weird thought comes in: What if, as a rather good player of Mafia he knows how to know these things and predict what others will do/think (much like me in RAF in IRC Mafia) and is using this to advantage, knowing that people will trust him (I still do, like I said - weird thought) but that is ultimately a cover up for being eviiiiil, kinda like a double bluff. And there's my really weird theory that makes no sense because it also works if Defiant is a passenger but: The reason he took so long to confirm his role was because he was asking questions to the host about it and due to a timezone difference of some-sort the answers were delayed and therefore lead to Defiant to be the last person to confirm... Then there's the larger possibility he was just inactive or was asking whether is roleplay character would be allowed.

Like I said, weird thought, probably something not to be followed because I for some strange reason trust Defiant (even though that still is proving the first half of my thought Dx)

Read my posts D:<

odd i seem to have missed that one, it appears that with all the activity between the active members in here i'm missing some. may i ask which page you posted it on so i could go back and look more thorougly through that page?

as for your theory It's interesting though a little complex, I however for one think the question asking could be part of it, or just as easily he could've been away for a few days. not to mention it could've easily been questions asked about a more complex towny role, though honestly it's more likely he was just away or forgot to respond. More importantly However i feel even using /making this argument goes against the spirit of the game as set forth by the instructions and rules our kind host gmk has provided us, I'd rather Not play that way as it tends to alter the deciding factors (whether for or against either side) and ruin the fun a bit for players on both sides.

 

[Vatumok]

Alright, I'll end the day now with the last nolynch vote, as currently the only thing we are doing is blaming one another of being mafia. We shouldn't work too chaotic or the mafia will definitely win and therefore we should work together and not blame anyway you think is the tiniest bit suspicious.

unvote
vote No Lynch

 

[Mooglie]

After a day of heated battle and discussion someone stands up and votes no-lynch, the last vote of the day. Some people cheer, some people sigh, some people just walk away. I don't sigh or cheer, I remain still for a bit then go to my room and have a quick swig of grog before I go to bed! I quickly scribble down in my notebook in my best handwriting... take into consideration I'm drunk... "Day 0 ends with a no-lynch, aka a free ticket for the mafia to kill. Time for day 1... Hopefully we'll have more information!"

 

[GmK]

~~~​

It was a long day. And one thing got very clear: A more diverse crowd of people could not have been assembled on the MS BEAGLE II. From constantly drunk fellows up to bodybuilding loving Rocks, it seemed like a whole panopticum got together.

Talk was a plenty - results weren't. Some were frustrated - others not so much. Especially those that did not end up being thrown over board...

The night fell swift across the ship. And with uncertain thoughts most people fell asleep. Most...

~~~​

Spoiler: Final Vote Count

Players needed to lynch: 16
Players needed to no-lynch: 15

No Lynch - 15 - digitalmez, shinyshark, grimmjowforever, K1ngHoward, infernofox, mariosatr, ansoro, kraby1, Prizyms, balloon98, HypeBurst, myusername22, storm886, Jivvi, Vatumok (NL-0)
K1ngHoward - 1 - MarsKid (L-15)
myusername22 - 2 - nottykitten, endersteve5 (L-14)
Defiant_Blob - 4 - cooliorules, One One Two, Sploorky, Dessern5 (L-12)

Players not voting: Alpha102, Ooglie, 77_is_the_best, hihihilolHI, Old_Man_Oak_63, Omar_Sales, nitasu987, Defiant_Blob

End of Day 0 - Start of Night 1.​

​

MafiaPlayer​

​

All Power Roles, please submit your actions to me in your PM. Even if you don't plan on using one, send me a simple "none".

Thread will reopen once all nightly actions are over.

Good night - and good luck.​

​

 

[GmK]

~~~​

Most people were so tired, that they fell asleep quickly, and upon waking up it seemed like they had only just fallen asleep - despite 8 hrs having passed.​

​

Upon getting onto the main deck, everyone made a gruesome discovery: A sole hand was lying on a silver platter, cut off roughly, with parts of the bone still sticking out. A body was nowhere to be found. ​

​

Upon a first count of people it got very clear: That hand must have belonged to MarsKid...but since the body was missing, nobody was able to know anything about who the person actually was...​

~~~​

​

​

End of Night 1​

MarsKid was killed. ​

(No information about his role / alignment available)​

​

~~~​

​

Start of Day 1​

​

MafiaPlayer​

 

[Nottykitten]

Hmmm, interresting yet odd.

My possible ideas on the night:
1. Only 1 kill. Maybe only one big mafia team.
2. Maybe a Lucky/bulletproof person has been hit by other faction(s).
3. Maybe Vig decided not to shoot anyone.
4. Maybe sk did so as well.
5. Maybe not a sk this round.
6. This killing role makes it so people don't know what role died.
7. MarsKid was a goo.

I'm happy with only one person being dead. But it's confusing as we don't even know if that player was mafia or not. So basicly as I kept saying "yesterday".... We are in about the exact same situation as day 0 =/

 

[Ansoro2112]

I felt bad... I never had the time to get to know MarsKid. What kind of cruel human being can be capable of doing such monstrosity. Just the hand... Not even the body.

"Stay focus. Don't panic. Remember, you're almost with him" I say to myself. Its time to get to know these people a little bit more. This might just be the beginning of living nightmare.

 

[Vatumok]

I'm happy with only one person being dead. But it's confusing as we don't even know if that player was mafia or not. So basicly as I kept saying "yesterday".... We are in about the exact same situation as day 0 =/

That's nonsense, a night gives town roles a chance to investigate and this time at the cost of only 1 person (whether mafia, passenger or 3rd). 1-2 person dead every night would mean that there is more than enough time to investigate for cop role(s).

You are endersteve5 are still on top of my suspicion list.

 

[Vino]

THE BOuLDER cannot believe this death. THE BOuLDER should have heard a scream or something while he was power lifting at 4 AM. THE BOuLDER also notes that MarKid voted for KingHoward. THE BOuLDER note that there should be a reason to why Mar's was killed if he voted for someone, since killing of a lynch vote early game usualy raises suspicion, there had to be a good incentive to do it. THE BOuLDER thinks the mafia are trying to throw suspician at Kind Howard and THE BOuLDER sees King Henry as somewhat innocent. THE BOuLDER in honor of Cing Howrawd will now go for a nice relaxing 17 mile dash while carrying orphaned children and singed to them.

 

[Nottykitten]

I'm happy with only one person being dead. But it's confusing as we don't even know if that player was mafia or not. So basicly as I kept saying "yesterday".... We are in about the exact same situation as day 0 =/

That's nonsense, a night gives town roles a chance to investigate and this time at the cost of only 1 person (whether mafia, passenger or 3rd). 1-2 person dead every night would mean that there is more than enough time to investigate for cop role(s).

You are endersteve5 are still on top of my suspicion list.

That is true but I am not the cop so I have no other information other than mars died last night =/