The Economy of Madness - Game Complete!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
role name would provide no useful information other than possibly feeding an RID ammunition

coins would also provide no useful information to town from what i can see atleast, as it could only be used to figure out how to kill someone or how many times someone can use their action

a role claim now would force mafia to have to speedily put together a claim that may not fit a situation they find themselves in in like 2+ days time & i feel like it could be possible to distinguish a fake claim by looking at how much the economic panic scale thingy shifts BUT i havent looked into that yet so dont quote me!!

but ya it also exposes useful town roles but thats what any mass claim does! its just whether the rewards outweigh the risks, which i think they will but i pretty much support a mass claim in every game ever so i guess someone unbiased should give their opinion
honestly i'll be real with you all and say i skimmed through notty and inf's arguing and i blame being ill

if one more person calls <o> a person with hands against their head then i will shoot you all

it's a valid argument but after like 1 town death it'll be easy to see if town roles have complexities (but obviously not all of them will i guess) but following this train of logic i guess i'd be ok with postponing the massclaim to like day 1 after a town person would have presumably died during the night (but then that also does defeat the purpose of this massclaim being sprung on mafia to force them to come up with a fake claim without conferring (i assume they only have night chat atleast!))

also, im not sure why people have suddenly begun claiming some of their role name when its pretty much completely useless (imo) and iirc the RID killer in the pearled bridge functioned around getting like 50% of the name right (i know that people changed up words but still as a warning!) but i might be remembering incorrectly BUT i will say that i also have a generic name in my role name like mischief so i guess role names might be inconsistent throughout town to avoid calling people out purely on that? alternatively theres some 3p role which needs to kill everyone with a name in their role name in which case bye i guess im dead!!!
why is memeing inappropiate on day 0!
i'm gon be honest with y'all im getting bad juju vibes from notty
(i love you im sorry <3)
but then thats a red flag!
im willing to do this i guess even though i dont think it will help much!
These are the posts that contributed to my impression of you

Also I found this while I was looking back:

i don't trust the question!
(but no my rolename starts with [generic name] i think i said this before IM 100% GONNA BE RID KILLED NOW but i refuse to answer if it has a 'the' in it or not)
I feel pretty confident in saying the ones who have already revealed part of their rolename are probably town since I don't think scum would of joined so soon.
look i'm just tryna stay alive
Seems pretty manipulative to know oog's role name for someone who just wants it for harmless info imo since manipulation like that, i think, tends to come out more in desperate situations? but maybe not

It reads to me like

'I don't trust the question so I won't say'

'People who did looked really townie hint hint'
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Also since the first couple quotes are quite big I should be more specific:

"a role claim now would force mafia to have to speedily put together a claim that may not fit a situation they find themselves in in like 2+ days time & i feel like it could be possible to distinguish a fake claim by looking at how much the economic panic scale thingy shifts BUT i havent looked into that yet so dont quote me!!"

"but ya it also exposes useful town roles but thats what any mass claim does!"

"it's a valid argument but"
(I don't really feel as though this is as sunshiny as I did before though but at the time it just seemed weird you'd be like 'it's valid but...' rather than just the 'but...')

(i know that people changed up words but still as a warning!)

 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
"a role claim now would force mafia to have to speedily put together a claim that may not fit a situation they find themselves in in like 2+ days time & i feel like it could be possible to distinguish a fake claim by looking at how much the economic panic scale thingy shifts BUT i havent looked into that yet so dont quote me!!"
...how is that sunshiney
"but ya it also exposes useful town roles but thats what any mass claim does!"
...how is that sunshiney
"it's a valid argument but" (I don't really feel as though this is as sunshiny as I did before though but at the time it just seemed weird you'd be like 'it's valid but...' rather than just the 'but...')
since it was a newly proposed argument that actually made me have to think for like a minute rather than instantly dismiss like every other argument proposed

"why is memeing inappropiate on day 0!"

i felt bad that people were rudely coming after omni, sue me???

"i'm gon be honest with y'all im getting bad juju vibes from notty
(i love you im sorry <3)"

woah... i apologised to notty for being susp... thats so unlike me...

"but then thats a red flag!"


... how is that sunshiney

"im willing to do this i guess even though i dont think it will help much!"

surprisingly im willing to do something that will (hopefully) cascade into a full massclaim (which they literally wrote in the post) which ive been supporting

Seems pretty manipulative to know oog's role name for someone who just wants it for harmless info imo since manipulation like that, i think, tends to come out more in desperate situations? but maybe not

It reads to me like

'I don't trust the question so I won't say'

'People who did looked really townie hint hint'
i agree but seemingly everyone else shares this opinion + idrc at this point since im p sure that without a mass claim im gonna be x_x'd tonight (just a gut feeling i have!) + this seems like a 3p motive and i truly have no care if a 3p wins alongside town or not
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
...how is that sunshiney

...how is that sunshiney

since it was a newly proposed argument that actually made me have to think for like a minute rather than instantly dismiss like every other argument proposed

"why is memeing inappropiate on day 0!"

i felt bad that people were rudely coming after omni, sue me???

"i'm gon be honest with y'all im getting bad juju vibes from notty
(i love you im sorry <3)"

woah... i apologised to notty for being susp... thats so unlike me...

"but then thats a red flag!"


... how is that sunshiney

"im willing to do this i guess even though i dont think it will help much!"

surprisingly im willing to do something that will (hopefully) cascade into a full massclaim (which they literally wrote in the post) which ive been supporting
no it's not about what you're actually saying

you're using ! a lot to soften the posts, that's my impression

for example rather than 'why is meming inapprioriate day 0' you add the ! to make it more *higher pitched smily voice*

and that's the impression i get from all of those posts, not the words you're saying, the way you're softening them

it reminds me of how someone in fallout 3 speaks let me see if i can find them
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
id encourage you to read over my post history but i feel like youre not tryhard enough to do that
even if you don't do it as much i guess it's not just the fact you're using them it's how i feel they're being used? something about them, idk what, makes me think theyre more desperate to soften than they usually are if that makes sense
 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
+ i dont remember you feeling the need to do that as town before e.g. in republic
maybe when notty was openly a non-town role that was holding the town's fate in their hands (as pretending to be whatever that thingy was) but yes if i pick up bad vibes on notty on day 0 i am going to apologise
even if you don't do it as much i guess it's not just the fact you're using them it's how i feel they're being used? something about them, idk what, makes me think theyre more desperate to soften than they usually are if that makes sense
youre wrong and basing an entire argument over !s and not the content of the post is bad and you should feel bad
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
maybe when notty was openly a non-town role that was holding the town's fate in their hands (as pretending to be whatever that thingy was) but yes if i pick up bad vibes on notty on day 0 i am going to apologise
hm fair enough she was openly third party then

youre wrong and basing an entire argument over !s and not the content of the post is bad and you should feel bad
i'm not even saying i think you're mafia, i said it wasn't a huge concern since you usually come off to me like that when you're ill

i'm not acting like it's a big argument that makes you scum it's just an impression i've noticed and nobody should feel bad about sharing impressions!
 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
i'm not even saying i think you're mafia, i said it wasn't a huge concern since you usually come off to me like that when you're ill

i'm not acting like it's a big argument that makes you scum it's just an impression i've noticed and nobody should feel bad about sharing impressions!
if you dont town-read me, your living god, then yes i will perceive it as scum reading (especially from you!) and fight back

and people should watch their mouth when talking about me or i'll steal their tongue

IS THIS THE OOG YOU WANTED INF
SINCE YOUVE AWOKEN HIM
 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
Because why is it interesting, why does it matter I don't understand
99% sure notty was trying to make me feel uncomfortable and slip if i was mafia (even though im town i felt an extraordinary amount of pressure and scaredness)!

im intentionally gonna end all my sentences with !s now just for you!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top