The Pearled Bridge - Game Complete!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
To continue my trend of tagging people Inf also individually tags, TheWeakGuy48_ do you think it's time to place your vote? You've said you would place your vote on Inf and that you were willing to give me the chance to be proven tonight (and if I'm not lynch me tomorrow(?))


Thats exactly what you asked. It not being objective is exactly the point because you make it look like it's objective 'reasons to lynch notty' 'reasons to lynch me' in big bold letters but they aren't actual reasons they're faulty opinions and stacked against me. You clearly meant it to manipulate people because why else would you put 'reasons to lynch me' there with only 1 argument if not to pretend there aren't any arguments against you. What doy ou mean I'm piggy backing onto claire and omni, I've been calling you out for manipulation for ages and now they are too
I never said it was an objective thing. I said it was my argument to lynch notty at the bottom.

you thanked claire and omni for calling me out and agreed with what they were saying, right? so I want you to put it into your own words why you agree with their specific points - the things they called me out for, why that's manipulative to you

or if I'm just misunderstanding what you meant then say so
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
I never said it was an objective thing. I said it was my argument to lynch notty at the bottom.

you thanked claire and omni for calling me out and agreed with what they were saying, right? so I want you to put it into your own words why you agree with their specific points - the things they called me out for, why that's manipulative to you

or if I'm just misunderstanding what you meant then say so
You're misunderstanding and you know very well how manipulative it is to say 'why you should vote notty' in big bold underlined letters, provide it with 4 reasons and then 'why you should vote me' in big bold underlined letters and provide it with 1 reason. This is manipulative. Stop pretending it isn't. I don't care that you wrote they were your reasons at the bottom of the post, they make it look as if there is nothing against you and everything against me. You had exactly 0 reason to include 'why you should vote me' in big bold underlined letters if you were just formatting your arguments against me unless you wanted to manipulate people. You had exactly 0 reason to compare arguments against you vs arguments against me (and leaving out plenty vs you) unless you wanted to manipulate people.

Stop pretending it wasn't the most manipulative thing ever because it was. You're pretending as if a single line at the end of your posts makes any different when you know very well that styling, formatting, subtext and implying things are all ways you manipulate people and you're doing it all in this post.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
You're misunderstanding and you know very well how manipulative it is to say 'why you should vote notty' in big bold underlined letters, provide it with 4 reasons and then 'why you should vote me' in big bold underlined letters and provide it with 1 reason. This is manipulative. Stop pretending it isn't. I don't care that you wrote they were your reasons at the bottom of the post, they make it look as if there is nothing against you and everything against me. You had exactly 0 reason to include 'why you should vote me' in big bold underlined letters if you were just formatting your arguments against me unless you wanted to manipulate people. You had exactly 0 reason to compare arguments against you vs arguments against me (and leaving out plenty vs you) unless you wanted to manipulate people.

Stop pretending it wasn't the most manipulative thing ever because it was. You're pretending as if a single line at the end of your posts makes any different when you know very well that styling, formatting, subtext and implying things are all ways you manipulate people and you're doing it all in this post.
why are you avoiding my question?

put it into your own words why you agree with claire and omni's specific points against me, to prove you weren't just patting their backs on points you don't actually think make sense, in an attempt to manipulate them into keeping their votes onto me

the reason I made that post wasn't to be an objective guide for who to lynch, I made it as a case against you, I bolded it so that people skimming the thread would read it, and I put the thing at the bottom since if people think I'm more scummy than you then I believe they should vote for me. it wasn't about being manipulative
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
To make the 1-shot vig take 2-days, while also making sure they can change their mind inbetween if new info comes out about the primed target.
okay, why?

what's the difference between 'you can prime and change your mind if new information comes' vs 'you can kill someone once you're sure you want them dead'?
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
okay, why?

what's the difference between 'you can prime and change your mind if new information comes' vs 'you can kill someone once you're sure you want them dead'?
Excuse me is there a trait/power that is 'you can kill someone once you're sure you want them dead' that takes 2 days? Yes it's exactly the combination of prime/ignite
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Excuse me is there a trait/power that is 'you can kill someone once you're sure you want them dead' that takes 2 days? Yes it's exactly the combination of prime/ignite
the power that describes that perfectly is also kill, except it takes 1 day

so why were you given prime/ignite when it's only difference is to make it last 2 days?
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
why are you avoiding my question?
I'm not avoiding it but it takes more than 1 second to go back and find claires posts again instead I answered the question right in front of me. Give me more than 5 seconds thank you.

why are you avoiding my question?

put it into your own words why you agree with claire and omni's specific points against me, to prove you weren't just patting their backs on points you don't actually think make sense, in an attempt to manipulate them into keeping their votes onto me

See this screenshot, where claire says you're taking out the parts that support you even though the original post states otherwise. It's exactly what you've done. Arguing that you/hip/Oog know me best and they all think I'm scum therefor I must be scum. But conveniently ignoring that you're scum so this isn't an argument, hip is only lynching me for the prime/ignite thing and has nothing to do how well he knows me, and Oog also thinks you're scum (and is willing to let me prove myself). Arguing you all know me best so I have to be scum is manipulation because it's a faulty argument for reasons



also can you stop avoiding my question
Literally CAN YOU GIVE ME MORE THAN 5 SECONDS TO POSt I was gonna talk about Omni aswell but you know what you want a post her ehave an unfinished post above
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
the power that describes that perfectly is also kill, except it takes 1 day

so why were you given prime/ignite when it's only difference is to make it last 2 days?
....because Alpha wanted the vigilante role to take 2 days so they can't instantly kill someone. The power that perfectly describes it is not kill because that kills instantly and doesn't take 2 days.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
I'm not avoiding it but it takes more than 1 second to go back and find claires posts again instead I answered the question right in front of me. Give me more than 5 seconds thank you.



See this screenshot, where claire says you're taking out the parts that support you even though the original post states otherwise. It's exactly what you've done. Arguing that you/hip/Oog know me best and they all think I'm scum therefor I must be scum. But conveniently ignoring that you're scum so this isn't an argument, hip is only lynching me for the prime/ignite thing and has nothing to do how well he knows me, and Oog also thinks you're scum (and is willing to let me prove myself). Arguing you all know me best so I have to be scum is manipulation because it's a faulty argument for reasons
so you agree that leaving out the fact that oog thinks I'm mafia, when my point is 'oog, me and hip are all convinced you're mafia', is manipulation? you agree that those two things are relevant to each other?

why?
 

Unusual_Dood

Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2015
Messages
132
Reaction score
913
I believe it's to give the Mafia the roleblock ability, but with the added bonus that they can also in dire situations save one of their Mafia buddies at the cost of stopping their abilities (and to also fit the theme of a law person having the jail ability). Like where I today proclaim I am murdering Omni, if Omni & Inf are both Mafia the Mafia could jail Omni to save his life at the cost of blocking whatever his ability is.
Hmm, perhaps some usefulness but still think it’s more unlikely to be mafia than townie. I don’t feel like jailer is a mafia role and I have never seen it been before either.
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
so you agree that leaving out the fact that oog thinks I'm mafia, when my point is 'oog, me and hip are all convinced you're mafia', is manipulation? you agree that those two things are relevant to each other?

why?
You're even lying right now where you say your point is 'oog, me and hip are all convinced you're mafia' while your point actually was 'oog, me and hip all know Notty best and we all think they're Mafia, clearly the people who know Notty best would know if she's acting non-town' (btw you say Mafia here but should be third party or non-town but whatever that was a typo).

Maybe you're remembering your own argument wrong but saying that you 3 know me best so clearly all you 3 thinking I'm non-town should tell people that something's up is flawed because; its a lynch of you vs me ofcourse you'd say anything so whatever you say shouldn't even be a factor here, Hip thinks I'm non-town because of prime/ignite and it has nothing to do with how well he knows me so he shouldn't even be in this list either, leaving Oog who happens to be convinced you're scum aswell meaning that if he's right about me he surely has to be right about you which makes your argument flawed because it would imply you're Mafia.
 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
also Mooglie are you not sure notty is third party arsonist anymore then?


and if not, why do you think she was given prime and ignite as a 1-shot vig?
notty is probably third party arsonist
notty answered why above, i dont necessarily think its a good reason however there is a possibility it exists
notty will be proved/disproved tonight since a third party arsonist wouldnt have 1-shot abilities even more than a town vig wouldnt have 1-shot abilities
does this require matty being alive? yes
does taking notty out today change mattys fate overnight? no i dont think so (since i think youre claiming mafia will kill him since hes a strong PR as well as throwing shade on notty)
do i still want to lynch notty tomorrow if matty dies overnight? i think i mentioned this in a previous post but yeah
i'd prefer taking the slim possibility that notty gets proven overnight assuming theyre not lying and matty lives and also lynch you, who i am 100% certain of is mafia
its a win-win situation!
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
You're even lying right now where you say your point is 'oog, me and hip are all convinced you're mafia' while your point actually was 'oog, me and hip all know Notty best and we all think they're Mafia, clearly the people who know Notty best would know if she's acting non-town' (btw you say Mafia here but should be third party or non-town but whatever that was a typo).

Maybe you're remembering your own argument wrong but saying that you 3 know me best so clearly all you 3 thinking I'm non-town should tell people that something's up is flawed because; its a lynch of you vs me ofcourse you'd say anything so whatever you say shouldn't even be a factor here, Hip thinks I'm non-town because of prime/ignite and it has nothing to do with how well he knows me so he shouldn't even be in this list either, leaving Oog who happens to be convinced you're scum aswell meaning that if he's right about me he surely has to be right about you which makes your argument flawed because it would imply you're Mafia.
my argument is 'all three people who probably know notty best are convinced she's third party'

dismissing my argument 'because it's me vs you' is wrong because I was convinced of this before it became me vs you

and:

convinced inf is scum: oog
convinced oog is scum: noone
convinced notty is scum: oog, hip, inf

all three of us are convinced of you, we all come together to agree on this, that's my point - what oog thinks of me is irrelevant
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
why? why make it take 2 days to kill someone?
Whatever Alpha's reasons were we don't know it untill after the game, but I assume to make sure the town can't instantly kill someone and instead have to be more tactical (by dousing the right person the day before) adding another element of skill into the mix.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
does taking notty out today change mattys fate overnight? no i dont think so (since i think youre claiming mafia will kill him since hes a strong PR as well as throwing shade on notty)
I think matty will only be a target tonight if notty is alive, because if notty dies the incentive to kill matty is just 'he's a PR' but there are more threatening PRs out there than him to kill first (blockers)
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Whatever Alpha's reasons were we don't know it untill after the game, but I assume to make sure the town can't instantly kill someone and instead have to be more tactical (by dousing the right person the day before) adding another element of skill into the mix.
explain where 'skill' is in what you just said
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
mm i guess it is a fair tossup between blocker(s) and power inspect
I mean power inspect is way less valuable, like you pointed out earlier, most powers are irrelevant to alignment, meaning mafia can claim their true powers and not get outed by power inspect - which is why you thought using it on omni was pointless right?

blocker is way more powerful, it can stop their kill and out one of their team

if notty dies today, pretty sure matty's safe

if she doesn't, pretty sure matty dies
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top