Trouble in the West: Pirates vs Cowboys [Finished]
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
- Status
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
I'M GONNA TAKE A WILD STAB
I have a gut feeling those who haven't replied during the night (or have replied very little) may be scum, focussing on their night chat and what they're doing.
I have a gut feeling those who haven't replied during the night (or have replied very little) may be scum, focussing on their night chat and what they're doing.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Just assuming from epicmafia. I'm too used to that place.
Also, that's a good point xD
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
There's that Pixelmon server running. Trying to get my Larvesta a few more levels to make it blossom into a beautiful Volcarona \o/.
...Which I'm gonna go back to right after I finish answering that question.
Do you consider yourself to behave suspiciously? If yes, why? If no, why not?
Eh, not really in my opinion, but I must be doing something suspicious if I was vote-worthy off of nothing.
I don't tend to change up my playstyle, as I'm not the biggest fan of changing up my habits.
I've tried to speak my mind, and have, when I've gotten the chance or had the time, tried combated ideas that I feel are idiotic or illogical or shouldn't be taken as a good course of action when the evidence or information for such a practice has no purpose to be there (like that Duffie lynch, though it did result in a lucky result, that's all it was, lucky, and the premise for that vote I can't stop pulling my hair out over. ), which is a course of action I always try to do in every Mafia season, no matter which alignment. I don't like going along with a lynch unless I'm convinced to take a suspicion/reason to lynch with a degree of seriousness (aka. that I can agree with/see why its suspicious).
I feel I can trust most of my assumptions and stand by essentially all of my votes and reasonings. That doesn't necessarily say anything about suspicion, because that's all just an opinion, but whatever.
But I must be a tad suspicious in some regard by at least someone (again, there was that vote), though I guess everyone can basically be deemed suspicious due to something or other depending on the person, except I guess, 77, since he's the partyhost, which is generally a town role, right? (i've never heard of the partyhost until this night-party started, but the wiki says its town so I'm just going to go with that)
...Which I'm gonna go back to right after I finish answering that question.
Do you consider yourself to behave suspiciously? If yes, why? If no, why not?
Eh, not really in my opinion, but I must be doing something suspicious if I was vote-worthy off of nothing.
I don't tend to change up my playstyle, as I'm not the biggest fan of changing up my habits.
I've tried to speak my mind, and have, when I've gotten the chance or had the time, tried combated ideas that I feel are idiotic or illogical or shouldn't be taken as a good course of action when the evidence or information for such a practice has no purpose to be there (like that Duffie lynch, though it did result in a lucky result, that's all it was, lucky, and the premise for that vote I can't stop pulling my hair out over. ), which is a course of action I always try to do in every Mafia season, no matter which alignment. I don't like going along with a lynch unless I'm convinced to take a suspicion/reason to lynch with a degree of seriousness (aka. that I can agree with/see why its suspicious).
I feel I can trust most of my assumptions and stand by essentially all of my votes and reasonings. That doesn't necessarily say anything about suspicion, because that's all just an opinion, but whatever.
But I must be a tad suspicious in some regard by at least someone (again, there was that vote), though I guess everyone can basically be deemed suspicious due to something or other depending on the person, except I guess, 77, since he's the partyhost, which is generally a town role, right? (i've never heard of the partyhost until this night-party started, but the wiki says its town so I'm just going to go with that)
GmK
International Man Of Cake
Remember to also always check posts not only for their basic content, which can seem illogical, but also for role tells. If you only go by what is written and discredit it as being illogical (see the Duffie case), you can miss 70% of the actual game, which is people giving tells on what they actually know&are. If you only try to apply logic, you'll often be lead down a dangerous path, since it can block your actual judgement.
A nice read is e.g. this http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=JEEP's_Common_Tells but unfortunately he did not continue the series yet
---
@Ooglie101 mentioned that Inns cannot talk during this night? I do still wonder if that hints at also the pirates not being able to communicate (just going by my own games I host, where the mafia chat is also an "inn" in a way, in Bloody Masquerade they would have also lost the ability to daytalk if the Inn Keeper would have been killed off), making it harder for them to actually find a course of action?
Going by this train of thought I do actually have a FOS, but I don't want to follow up on it since it relies on knowing if they can chat or not.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Do you consider yourself to behave suspiciously? If yes, why? If no, why not?
I guess so, because I don't really have any solid hunches or anything as of yet. I have voted I think once this game, which was off a hunch. The other because, well, we may as well have ended the day a bit quicker - there was no going back.
And I just realised that's why Duffie voted and oh god that would look bad..... >_>
I guess so, because I don't really have any solid hunches or anything as of yet. I have voted I think once this game, which was off a hunch. The other because, well, we may as well have ended the day a bit quicker - there was no going back.
And I just realised that's why Duffie voted and oh god that would look bad..... >_>
We'll see I guess. Honestly, I don't think we should worry too much about that now, as all we can do is speculate. All we can do is wait for someone to die....wow...that's kinda dark, but it's all he have.
I think a good course of action would be to look at OMO's suspicions, as they hold much more weight now that he's been confirmed a townie...and we may not have any more confirmed townies ever x_x
I fear that this is quickly turning into a mafia victory. How many people are left?
I think a good course of action would be to look at OMO's suspicions, as they hold much more weight now that he's been confirmed a townie...and we may not have any more confirmed townies ever x_x
I fear that this is quickly turning into a mafia victory. How many people are left?
Mooglie
The Local Cow
Woop woop, it's the sound of the police.
Well Sheriffs.
HECK YEAH! Hello, my name is Ooglie101, or as I am called in this town - Sheriff Steve... I don't know what else to say really.
Night 1 I investigated Swate and he came up as innocent, which is why I went from attacking him harshly on Day 0 to not saying anything about him Day 1.
Night 2 I investigated Digitalmez but my results were delayed until last night.
Night 3 I received the investigation on Digitalmez - GUILTY. This was during the party but I wanted to save it for the day since if I revealed information and a possible doc had already made a save and couldn't change it to me and then the mafia came to kill me I would be screwed.
I investigated the remaining member of my inn last night but I can say that my results are still delayed and I wasn't told that I received the cursed tome last night so yay.
If anyone is curious, I did ask and I could not investigate myself or know if any Paranoid, Insane, etc roles existed. Since there were two cops it is possible that either me or Jivvi were paranoid. I will be voting Digi so if they come up as mafia/third party (not sure if third party falls into guilty) then I'd presume Swate is innocent or a godfather if one exists.
Seems like the tactic of playing suspiciously on the first few days to make the mafia think it'd be good if I stayed alive helps I guess \o/ And obviously I will...
vote digitalmez
Well Sheriffs.
HECK YEAH! Hello, my name is Ooglie101, or as I am called in this town - Sheriff Steve... I don't know what else to say really.
Night 1 I investigated Swate and he came up as innocent, which is why I went from attacking him harshly on Day 0 to not saying anything about him Day 1.
Night 2 I investigated Digitalmez but my results were delayed until last night.
Night 3 I received the investigation on Digitalmez - GUILTY. This was during the party but I wanted to save it for the day since if I revealed information and a possible doc had already made a save and couldn't change it to me and then the mafia came to kill me I would be screwed.
I investigated the remaining member of my inn last night but I can say that my results are still delayed and I wasn't told that I received the cursed tome last night so yay.
If anyone is curious, I did ask and I could not investigate myself or know if any Paranoid, Insane, etc roles existed. Since there were two cops it is possible that either me or Jivvi were paranoid. I will be voting Digi so if they come up as mafia/third party (not sure if third party falls into guilty) then I'd presume Swate is innocent or a godfather if one exists.
Seems like the tactic of playing suspiciously on the first few days to make the mafia think it'd be good if I stayed alive helps I guess \o/ And obviously I will...
vote digitalmez
Guys, my sense of impending doom is acting up ;-;
Also: I believe Ooglie's claim, as fake-able as it may be.
That means we have two cops. It's almost guaranteed that one of them is paranoid. That's a 50/50 chance that it's Ooglie. Ooglie got one inno and one guilty. That means that one of them is mafia. There is no way to guess which one. I'm more tempted to lynch Swate, but that's just my gut. I think both should claim (even though it's closed setup :/ ) and we could decide from there.
Also: I believe Ooglie's claim, as fake-able as it may be.
That means we have two cops. It's almost guaranteed that one of them is paranoid. That's a 50/50 chance that it's Ooglie. Ooglie got one inno and one guilty. That means that one of them is mafia. There is no way to guess which one. I'm more tempted to lynch Swate, but that's just my gut. I think both should claim (even though it's closed setup :/ ) and we could decide from there.
- Status