Trouble in the West: Pirates vs Cowboys [Finished]
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
- Status
The point is the alien is not a member of the mafia, therefore is part of the town population. If he really is alien, then he is one of the numbers keeping this game from going into lylo.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
No, it would lower the total number of players, while leaving the mafia still the same as they were, meaning we'd have less people again. Mafia needs to be half the total players, not half the town players.
GmK
International Man Of Cake
So right now that means to
- either believe in the lazy cop theory, which would mean Ooglie was correct (Swate Inno, Digi Guilty), and lynching Digi as a best bet (but that goes against my own feeling of Swate not being innocent, argh)
- or scumhunting within the other players hoping for a slip
Since the latter will require more time, I do hope we won't get a deadline soon, since this will force rash decisions yet again.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
I think we should scumhunt for the time we can't. If we can't get anyone to slip in time, go onto digi. She did just offer herself up on a plate. Generally when people do that, it's because there's something against them. I know that in epicmafia I will often say "okay yeah whatever vote me if you want lol" when I'm mafia, so that also does stick out to me. I'm gonna go through the previous pages and re read EVERYTHING.
See you guys when I'm bacckkkkkk xD
See you guys when I'm bacckkkkkk xD
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
I can understand Digi's hopelessness tbh. I mean, when Ooglie investigates her and gets a guilty result, and people start thinking maybe he was lazy and not insane, I'd be pretty hopeless too
Every one seems to think that ooglie is either insane or lazy, but why can't it be both?
We had two cops. Having two sane cops would just be...well, boring. There's no krazy konfusion there, and that' what this game's supposed to be about.
The Lazy modifier is believed to be caused by the death of Donut Dan. That means that it's a situational modifier. The main reason that people think it can only be one or the other is that having two negative modifiers would be a bit much. Thing is, though, one of them was caused by a death (that of Donut Dan), so he only started the game with one. ...I don't know how many of you followed that, but the point is I think Ooglie was a lazy insane cop.
We had two cops. Having two sane cops would just be...well, boring. There's no krazy konfusion there, and that' what this game's supposed to be about.
The Lazy modifier is believed to be caused by the death of Donut Dan. That means that it's a situational modifier. The main reason that people think it can only be one or the other is that having two negative modifiers would be a bit much. Thing is, though, one of them was caused by a death (that of Donut Dan), so he only started the game with one. ...I don't know how many of you followed that, but the point is I think Ooglie was a lazy insane cop.
GmK
International Man Of Cake
So, in your opinion and from that standpoint, how should we proceed? Deeming him insane & lazy is only of use if you can deduct a certain action from it, else it won't get you far.
The deduction gained from it is that lynching Digi would be a big mistake. Lynching her would only be acceptable if Ooglie had more investigations, but Digi is the only living player that he investigated.
To elaborate/clarify my previous response, and to stimulate activity (not that we've been inactive for long) :
What's the use of deeming him lazy and sane if all it gets us is a lynched townie and one step closer to lylo?
I think there is sufficient evidence to say that Swate was mafia, therefore deeming Ooglie insane, thus clearing Digi. The course of action is to not lynch Digi. If we find no further leads, then we can lynch the claimed third-party, as it's at least better than lynching a townie. However, I'd rather it not come to that, whether I believe Storm's claim or not.
This thread could be a little bit more active, with only 8/13 of the people alive having posted within the past 48 hours and only a couple pages for this whole day (which has stretched through multiple irl days). I can understand being a bit busy now and then, but we gotta at lest try to stay more active and hunt the Pirates. If nothing else, we can all try actually answering ansoro's questions he posted about a day and a half ago (which is only on the last page =S).
1. Who do you currently find the most suspicious? And why?
I'm really at a loss this time. I'm sticking with Storm, but at the same time like Hype said, we have to lynch someone from the mafia or we might really lose the game. Storm's words are... strange I must say. He seems like a third-party yet at the same time his words also make him seem like the Mafia.
My holidays are ending in three days and it seems that I would be really busy for the entire school term (my End-of-Year exams are coming fast), so I have to place studies as my main priority and therefore I haven't taken my time off to gather evidence because it would be really time-consuming. If I really can't cope with it I might have to drop out of this game ;-;
2. Who are you most likely to think is innocent at this point? Why?
Hype and Ender seems most innocent to me at this point. Hype like I've explained before, and Ender because the way he puts things around with his words as well as his tone really leads me to believe he is innocent.
3. Do you think Swate was town or anti-town?
Anti-town.
I'm really at a loss this time. I'm sticking with Storm, but at the same time like Hype said, we have to lynch someone from the mafia or we might really lose the game. Storm's words are... strange I must say. He seems like a third-party yet at the same time his words also make him seem like the Mafia.
My holidays are ending in three days and it seems that I would be really busy for the entire school term (my End-of-Year exams are coming fast), so I have to place studies as my main priority and therefore I haven't taken my time off to gather evidence because it would be really time-consuming. If I really can't cope with it I might have to drop out of this game ;-;
2. Who are you most likely to think is innocent at this point? Why?
Hype and Ender seems most innocent to me at this point. Hype like I've explained before, and Ender because the way he puts things around with his words as well as his tone really leads me to believe he is innocent.
3. Do you think Swate was town or anti-town?
Anti-town.
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
1. Who do you currently find the most suspicious? And why?
Storm is probably the most suspicious but I still think it's too risky at this point in the game to go gun-ho and lynch him, we dont have a deadline set so we still have time to look through and find scum-tells. The lurkers are really getting me nervous, I know std is at camp but he only made like two posts before (if he did more than I must have forgotten them :c).
2. Who are you most likely to think is innocent at this point? Why?
I would say the obvious answer of 77 because in my eyes he's basically cleared due to the party. Jkangaroo also because of the huge posts of logic that I largely agree with, (not really the Digi one though).
3. Do you think Swate was town or anti-town?
80% anti-town due to the whole night activities thing.
Storm is probably the most suspicious but I still think it's too risky at this point in the game to go gun-ho and lynch him, we dont have a deadline set so we still have time to look through and find scum-tells. The lurkers are really getting me nervous, I know std is at camp but he only made like two posts before (if he did more than I must have forgotten them :c).
2. Who are you most likely to think is innocent at this point? Why?
I would say the obvious answer of 77 because in my eyes he's basically cleared due to the party. Jkangaroo also because of the huge posts of logic that I largely agree with, (not really the Digi one though).
3. Do you think Swate was town or anti-town?
80% anti-town due to the whole night activities thing.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Just as a note, Sploorky was him before, maybe that's why you don't remember more posts?
1. Who do you currently find the most suspicious? And why?
Honestly, I'm at that point where I'm a bit.. not sure at all about anything.
2. Who are you most likely to think is innocent at this point? Why?
Same as my last answer, I'm not really sure or much right now.
3. Do you think Swate was town or anti-town?
I feel as if he was innocent
Not knowing doesn't help us. Say any of your suspicions, no matter how small. AThese questions are meant to start discussion, but we can't discuss if there's no subject....I know you've done this before (in other games), but you've also gotten posts pretty much exactly like this one. Honestly, I'd kind of expect it to change with as much as it's happened ;-;
I won't hold it against you, but posts like that just don't help, and it could just be an excuse to later say "But I answered the questions!" I'm not saying it is, but still :c
- Status