Trouble in the West: Pirates vs Cowboys [Finished]

[Enderfive]

If anyone was to have a scummy impression on me. It'd be 77. He's active fairly often in the Inns but during the main thread, He just seems to disappear almost completely.

And how exactly would you know, considering how you said you weren't in an inn...?

I can understand why many would be suspicious of the dude who doesn't post much, has not claimed a role, or even an inn (if anyone cared to notice).

To be honest, all you've done in this game has been either lurking, saying what everyone else has said or defending yourself when you feel like it. Your suspicions at the moment: me and GmK

GmK: He made me have to actually try to act like I have an opinion on everything in this game so he's obviously scum. No, but really. I always get scum feels from him whenever I've played with him but that's because I don't trust a guy who hosts a crazy game like Masquerade was <_<

Endersteve: I found it odd that he somehow finds logic within the 3-person vote scum thing considering he did it with Swate.

are conviniently the exact two persons who seem to be most suspicious of you recently. And, well, digi as well, but you would obviously say you suspect digi when she has an incriminating investigation result against her and people are still suspicious of her. After all, you gotta show you have at least one opinion of your own (not really though, but you chose the timing nicely, right at the point where there still are people to agree with you, but on the other hand also people to disagree with you, that does make it look like it might be your own opinion breaking away from the general one), otherwise people might think you're scum!

So basically, you've been lurking, showing very little opinion of your own, diverting suspicion off yourself and possibly discrediting those that seem to view yourself as suspicious. It's honestly starting to look like you will turn up as scum when you die or the game ends.

 

[Samlen]

std, you forgot two people, Jeercrul and Storm xP

 

[std1997]

And how exactly would you know, considering how you said you weren't in an inn...?



To be honest, all you've done in this game has been either lurking, saying what everyone else has said or defending yourself when you feel like it. Your suspicions at the moment: me and GmK



are conviniently the exact two persons who seem to be most suspicious of you recently. And, well, digi as well, but you would obviously say you suspect digi when she has an incriminating investigation result against her and people are still suspicious of her. After all, you gotta show you have at least one opinion of your own (not really though, but you chose the timing nicely, right at the point where there still are people to agree with you, but on the other hand also people to disagree with you, that does make it look like it might be your own opinion breaking away from the general one), otherwise people might think you're scum!

So basically, you've been lurking, showing very little opinion of your own, diverting suspicion off yourself and possibly discrediting those that seem to view yourself as suspicious. It's honestly starting to look like you will turn up as scum when you die or the game ends.

Whenever did I say I wasn't in an inn?? I don't believe I've ever said. I'm in the same inn as 77 so yes, I'd know if he replies more to our inn than in the main thread.

I also find it suspicious that JK and Samlen also both suddenly decided that Digi's claim was more trustworthy than Ooglie's almost immediately after I made my vote.

Another person I find suspicious is you, Ender. Almost immediately after GmK makes his post on a 3rd person vote is scum, which I still believe was just to make me come out and defend myself. You immediately jump on with it saying that I'm mafia because I'm defending myself more than I am making postzillas of opinions like JKangaroo.

std, you forgot two people, Jeercrul and Storm xP

Storm: He claimed Alien. I trust his claim and I believe he said his win-condition was town-sided so I trust him.

Jeercul: I'm sorry but I don't think I've really noticed you or been able to form any opinions about you. ;-;

 

[Enderfive]

Whenever did I say I wasn't in an inn?? I don't believe I've ever said. I'm in the same inn as 77 so yes, I'd know if he replies more to our inn than in the main thread.

That's the impression I got, as I pointed out in the very post you quoted.

I also find it suspicious that JK and Samlen also both suddenly decided that Digi's claim was more trustworthy than Ooglie's almost immediately after I made my vote.

Pretty sure that Jk still views Digi as suspicious.

Another person I find suspicious is you, Ender. Almost immediately after GmK makes his post on a 3rd person vote is scum, which I still believe was just to make me come out and defend myself. You immediately jump on with it saying that I'm mafia because I'm defending myself more than I am making postzillas of opinions like JKangaroo.

Yes, you already said that. Look, fact is, I view you as suspicious, I did before GmK's post (which, by the way, was not at all centered around the scumtell, the scumtell was merely another detail in his post against you, which you, of course, conviniently decided to ignore because it's easier to attack the scumtell). All GmK did was strenghten my suspicion of you by bringing in a line of thought that I had missed.

 

[Ansoro2112]

Jeer The Cruel- She's like a puzzle for me. Everything's she has posted so far doesn't alarm me but at the same time it doesn't bring me town like vibes either. She's like in the middle right now.

GeeEmKay- I have always tried to be careful about him. Since I know how good he's at this games. He's very good at convincing people and that's something we need to be careful. But rather than that I don't really see him suspicious right now.

SlenderSteve- Besides 77, he's the one I feel I can trust a little bit more. While there's some thing I don't quite agree about his posts I still feel like he might be town. But again, doesn't mean I'm not watching him.

Hurricane (Storm)- Claimed to be Alien. Might be lying and might be telling the truth. Either way he's Anti-Town and we should keep an eye on him. I am still thinking voting for him right now is not the smartest idea.

Hottie2112- Costa Rica needs to win against Holland.

Lilo&Stitch- He's been a quiet player the entire game. While he posts things every now and then, I feel like he's lurking for some reason. That's what I said in the start of this thread, I don't like lurkers. They usually get to the end because they fly under the radar. He might be one of my FoS as for right now.

TimBro- I honeslty don't know what to think about him. There's sometimes his posts make sense to me but there are moments I'm like "The fuck?". He's like in the middle for me right now.

JKoala- I would buy your books. No but really, I always try to read his posts VERY carefully. Because I know how easy is to convince or impress people by how long your posts are. Right now I don't find him suspicious though, I feel he might be more town than anything else.

Salmon- I love the term "Mini JK". I think that fits perfect. He's been pretty active lately. Most of the things he have said so far make sense to me. He hasn't really made me nervous as for right now.

Maori (HypeBurst)- Hype is one of the players that are so hard to read. It's always a struggle for me. I always try to be careful but so far what he has posted doesn't really sound suspicious to me.

Cool I Totally Rule- I already got used to Coolio's way of playing. If you think about it it can be used to her advantage since everyone's like "Classic Coolio". I always try to see past that and focus on what she is really trying. She's in the middle for me right now. Can't really say much about it.

Digimon- She was one of the most suspicious people but she has managed to bring some good point that is making people trust her. Personally, it's 50-50 for me still. I want to be able to trust her but at the same time I feel there's something going on.

77_is_the_most_quiet_player_ever- I believe the only one right now who I think is town. But for god sake. Please talk a little bit more!! We still need your help here!

 

[cooliorules]

(in brackets if it seemed to me that you deemed the person slightly suspicious)

In that case, mine should all be in brackets for now

I also don't believe she mentioned her win-condition unless I missed something.

She claimed town. So her win condition would be to win with the town conditions.

hosts a crazy game

Pfft this is probably more crazy then what GmK hosted.

 

[cooliorules]

Ansoro I freaking love your names. You are amazing.

Now let me read them.

 

[cooliorules]

Inactivity alone I was suspicious of std. With what GmK has provided, that enlarges my suspicion. I will hold off with my vote for now, however.

 

[cooliorules]

I believe the only one right now who I think is town.

He's basically confirmed. He stated about the party (not directly, but still said something about it), so he knew about it. It's more common for people to be town when they're the aprty host. He's virtually confirmed.
Not really a case of "I think" anymore.

But for god sake. Please talk a little bit more!! We still need your help here!

A confirmed town who doesn't talk. Absolute. Useless.
Well, apart from the fact you make up part of the mass keeping us alive.

@77_is_the_best please, for the love of god, start helping us out a bit.

 

[HypeBurst]

Hypeburst: egotistical but that's just because that's how he is \o/

I take it you don't like me as such <3

Also, I was planning on doing a recap of everyone's suspicions like what GmK did but I was gonna wait until everyone has answered. I think before any votes are made, we should hear from everyone. (I'm pretty sure not everyone has answered but I could be wrong :c )

 

[cooliorules]

(I'm pretty sure not everyone has answered but I could be wrong :c )

77. Is. The. Notbest.

That is all.

 

[cooliorules]

People who have put the thoughts of others:

Cooliorules
GmK
Endersteve5
Ansoro2112
std1997
Samlen
Hypeburst
JKang

Total: 9

Living players: 13

Those who haven't typed up stuff:
77_is_the_best (not tagging because did recently)
@storm886
@Jeercrul (I thought you had, but went through. May have missed it)
@Timdood3

 

[cooliorules]

Holy god damn.

I tagged people, but I'll leave that out.

I also didn't count, so the total that have replied is 8. Not 9.

 

[cooliorules]

Oh only person I missed with the tagging was Digi. You're fairly active so it should be all goods.

 

[HypeBurst]

I thought Jeer did do it? well a compressed version I guess. I know she's under a lot of stress right now with school so I dont think we need to wait for her because we have her suspicions already. Digi also did a compressed version aswell so I guess we are only waiting for 77 and storm now.

 

[GmK]

And Tim is away for a week/month (?)

 

[Samlen]

Been a little quiet recently, was hoping a little to get some more responses from the five that haven't completely told us their viewpoints on everyone else by now, but we still do have a decent bit of information to go off of.

The person whom seems to stand out the most is std, and I can see why, from being so quiet. I was initially only suspicious of him for his quietness, but when GmK pointed out that he only popped up was to defend himself, it made me a fair bit more suspicious of him (though I still need to double check on GmK's find, I think it's mostly true at the very least). A couple of other people seem to be falling into the 'suspicious' or 'not suspicious' category, but std seems to be the one standing out the most to people. I'll probably try to put everyone into more organized categories once the last five post their thoughts on everyone.

 

[digi]

I don't feel that std is scum. I feel that the only thing he's guilty of is lurking. @std1997 - My win condition is to make sure that all threats to the Cowboys are eliminated.

 

[storm886]

I'm on vacation right now with no access to a computer so I will try when I can.

 

[cooliorules]

How long will you be on vacation for?

 

[storm886]

Four more days.

 

[77thShad]

I'm kind of keeping up but I haven't really had much to say.
I'll answer questions when I am on my computer tomorrow but I'll leave this overnight.

If we're going off that there is one mafia per room then it's either Sam or Std because coolio claimed something that I find very believable.

 

[cooliorules]

If we're going off that there is one mafia per room then it's either Sam or Std because coolio claimed something that I find very believable.

Seeing there's already suspicion on std, that could be somewhat a bit of like evidence sorta? Idk it's late and I'm tired and I don't know what I'm saying

 

[GmK]

Seeing there's already suspicion on std, that could be somewhat a bit of like evidence sorta? Idk it's late and I'm tired and I don't know what I'm saying

I am - personally - quite sure there isn't always one scum per inn, not in a game that mixes things up this much, after all the setup is to especially confuse those people that think to 'know' how mafia games work. So from a very basic standpoint I wouldn't rely on the theory.

But - it is indeed yet another point that adds to my suspicion of std... So it's not really helping him at the moment as well.

 

[GmK]

But to add to this: when did coolio claim? Did I miss something? Where do you get this from, 77?