ZUPLAR INVASION - GAME OVER - TOWN WIN

Iggish

Member
Joined
May 31, 2014
Messages
359
Reaction score
827
I'm not home yet, and so won't make a full proper post or analysis yet, but this is horrible reasoning to assume one is mafia. Drug dealer is a role that sounds criminal by name, but that could easily just be how inf is picking the theme. I also have a role that is townsided but is criminal by name so I know infected isn't just picking pretty sounding names for town and criminal names for mafia.
That was just my train of thought when asked what I think of both their roles and out of the two of them which is more suspicious. I'm not going to try and lynch someone based off the name, it was simply my line of thinking.
 

Fog

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 24, 2012
Messages
62
Reaction score
991
If there is an actress/tailor role then he may show up watcher/I might show up another role so if we do lynch between us please find a way to confirm the other.

Such as telling us a person to watch and one of us trying to confirm a visit. Just in case
I know this IS a possibility, but isn't it also a way to protect yourself if/when HK flips Town?
 

myusername22

A username.
Donor
Joined
Dec 17, 2012
Messages
858
Reaction score
937
Sorry I haven't been playing much these last few days. I was hoping to read through the thread and do a detailed post of my thoughts yesterday, but I was exhausted from only having 4 hours of sleep and fell asleep instead. Real life kind of caught up to me on Sunday, so I haven't made a significant post in a while. If I remember I will definitely do that tonight.
 

Fog

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 24, 2012
Messages
62
Reaction score
991
May I say, how are we sure the confirmation would be accurate, for all we know one of you could be mafia and get one of your buddies to confirm your story or one of you could investigate a mafia member and then deny the truth?
 
D

Deleted member 4601

Guest
I'll just put this out if y'all ever need the information since HK mentioned that he visited me last night - I didn't receive anything that would suggest that I was visited by someone. That wouldn't rule out the possibility that I was visited by someone though, nor does it mean that I'm saying that HK is right.

I swear, this is what going to happen every night
Regarding Unu's role, the role name sounds somewhat conspicuous, though I suppose with all the roles so far it's safe to say that Inffy's ability to comp up with space related roles aren't great. One question, though - why did you pick that target specifically, and what do you think of your ability to give hallucinations?

(woof)
 

Unusual_Dood

Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2015
Messages
132
Reaction score
913
One question, though - why did you pick that target specifically, and what do you think of your ability to give hallucinations?
There's no really reason for it. I wanted to use my ability and out of all I found Vino a player that could be a mafia.


I feel like the hallucinations might give clues to who innocent. Here's the text notty figured out:

"ONE RECORDED EXAMPLE OF A MEMBER OF A DIFFERENT SPECIES EXPERIENCING THIS PHENOMENON DETAILED HOW, IN HALLUCINATIONS, THINGS OF NATURE - WATER, FIRE, AIR, LIFE AND DEATH - REPRESENTED AND WERE OFTEN ASSOCIATED WITH THE *GOOD*"

As it said in the text it could mean that a player in someone's hallucination with things of nature, is "good". And I would say that "Weak feeding a deer" is things of nature. However, if I visit mafias they could lie about what they dreamed about. If this is true, I find my ability powerful.
 

Fog

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 24, 2012
Messages
62
Reaction score
991
90% sure foggy is also mafia since he us tunneling very hard on me and not considering another possibility.
Yes, because I want to hear from both HK and you before I make a judgement.

I have stated I found Notty the most suspicious and was sort of suspicious of Unu

Look the current dilemma is 'which Watcher is which?' and therefore I am asking both of you questions, however, you are the only one coming up with ideas that could potentially be flawed and I am pointing them out to the rest of the players. I wouldn't say personally I am 'tunneling' you specifically, however, this Watcher lead is the only thing we have to go off so far.
 

Vino

Fidget Spinner
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
382
Reaction score
741
Under the assumption I was mafia what benefit is their to counter claiming a watcher in a closed setup? All I'd be doing is giving town a 50/50 for a free catch. It would be more beneficial to stay hidden and claim a safe role later on.


However if I am town then counter claiming forces a 50/50 for a free mafia, so even if I'm lynched today, he will be lynched tomorrow for a 1 for 1 trade


Furthermore under the assumption that it is unknown who the liar is between us it'd more in towns favor to lynch HK first since if he ends up being town you have me and a false claim on a drug dealer.


Too add on too this HK also seems to have mafia experience so I doubt that slip on him saying I CCd him when I never claimed is something to note.
 
Top