Supernatural Hotel [Finished]
- Thread starter Alisha
- Start date
- Status
Notty has alot of influence. And likely a plan to do something with it.
You seem to be speaking lightly about town PRs getting killed. Much of your stated plan involves the cop. What if the cop gets killed? What if we lynch the cop? There's too many what ifs. Not to mention that the mafia now has a bigger chance to kill the cop or a town PR with 4 people out of the way. You may have doomed us notty. And we all are partially at fault, but this is how failures work.
The person with the most power, faces the most consequences.
You seem to be speaking lightly about town PRs getting killed. Much of your stated plan involves the cop. What if the cop gets killed? What if we lynch the cop? There's too many what ifs. Not to mention that the mafia now has a bigger chance to kill the cop or a town PR with 4 people out of the way. You may have doomed us notty. And we all are partially at fault, but this is how failures work.
The person with the most power, faces the most consequences.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
The only power it took to do that was convincing a few people to do it, and after that others were forced to or they would look anti-town. And if I had so much power I wouldn't be lynched now wouldn't I?
I haven't said anything about my plan being about the cop, my plan is to make sure we have the upper hand against the mafia. While even though most of you seem to not think the same, we have. The only thing I said about the cop is that he/she should investigate one of the proven people to find out of he/she is a sane or paranoid cop. I haven't said that we should rely on the cop at all.
Sorry @Alpha102 guess we will have to lynch you =D
Ansoro2112
Hottie
First of all I still don't trust 100% HypeBurst, Ltin, Ooglie and Coolio. I'm hoping everyone was honest about telling the truth if they're regular guests or not. In this twisted game you never know what's going on in someone's mind. Maybe a regular guest just decided to claim as a PR or Mafia/Third Party claim a regular guest. <--- I'm just trying to say to not trust that yet.
My opinion about the cop: I think he/she should out today. Std was luckily killed the first night and the next cop can be luckily killed again next. I really don't want to take that risk in not knowing what his/her investigation was. But that's just me.
I've seen all this talk about Notty. While there's some good points I'm still not completely sure about that. I'm going to go ahead and go back and read some posts. But so far I'm worried about lynching a random person. I'm leaning more towards voting no lynch.
My opinion about the cop: I think he/she should out today. Std was luckily killed the first night and the next cop can be luckily killed again next. I really don't want to take that risk in not knowing what his/her investigation was. But that's just me.
I've seen all this talk about Notty. While there's some good points I'm still not completely sure about that. I'm going to go ahead and go back and read some posts. But so far I'm worried about lynching a random person. I'm leaning more towards voting no lynch.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
However, we don't know if the cop is sane or not so his investigation means nothing atm. And then the cop will be roleblocked by the mafia so we won't have any further investigations after that. So I don't think it's that good of an idea if the cop outs today.
Firstly, I really don't see the point of regular guests claiming as PRs. Regular guests are all on the town's side, and it wouldn't do any good to help the mafia by claiming as PRs. They also have a better chance of survival, or should I say, close to immunity considering how their roles are known and mafia preferring to go for the PRs.
Secondly, I quite frankly see no point in the cop outing today when he/she barely has no leads and doesn't know his/her full identity yet. The cop being luckily killed is just an 1 in a 15 chance and is not a high probability at all.
As for me, I am definitely against a no-lynch considering how we have a better chance of hitting mafia since the guests have been revealed. I was also initially with notty since I pretty much agreed with her ideas. I didn't see agree to lynching her since I pretty much thought her as innocent. However, Sploorky's post made a lot of sense to me and re-analysing the stuff that notty has said, I can't help but find her guilty as well. I don't have anything else to say, seeing what's on my mind has been said.
HOWEVER, atm I find Ansoro scummier as compared to Notty. While Sploorky's post does make sense, there is still a part of me that still wants to trust Notty. Imo from the past mafia games, Ansoro has always been someone who is very logical, direct, straight to the point, and someone who can put up a good argument when challenged.
What I see from his post above instead, is hesitation and twisting of words to make his ideas sound logical in order to convince and/or manipulate us. The post about me posting that you were my FOS was simply me testing the waters. I expected you to put up a good explanation or at least attempt to defend yourself like you always would. However, you didn't.
This has in fact, led me to believe that you are part of the anti-town, hence, instead of voting notty, I choose to
Vote ansoro2112
Ansoro2112
Hottie
Exactly. There's no point of a regular guest claiming a PR but again, you never know what's on people's head. Maybe they have their own reason to claim PR. That's me being paranoid.
Again, I just don't want our last cop to be killed next night without knowing who he/she investigated. It's better something than nothing. If that cops gets killed I'm going to laugh at your face.
And Grim, where in the hell I'm "manipulating" people? I'm just saying I don't trust completely all the claims. You would be stupid if you believe it. Since you NEVER know if people are being honest or not.
Of course, vote me for giving my opinion. Yes, I don't trust the claims 100% and I think the cop should out because I'm being paranoid and I don't want him/her to be killed next. Vote me please. I'm so dangerous.
Here's your friendly neighborhood vote count. Let's work on keeping it this way, please.
Nottykitten-3(GmK, endersteve5, xXxFruitNinjaxXx)[L-7]
Ansoro2112-1(Jeercrul)[L-9]
No Lynch-3(Nottykitten, Fiestaguy, raxo2222)[NL-7]
Nottykitten-3(GmK, endersteve5, xXxFruitNinjaxXx)[L-7]
Ansoro2112-1(Jeercrul)[L-9]
No Lynch-3(Nottykitten, Fiestaguy, raxo2222)[NL-7]
Ansoro2112
Hottie
Note: I've said this every season and I will say it again. My playstyle is very aggressive and sarcastic. To the point where you might think I'm being serious. But I'm not! It's nothing personal and I'm not even upset! So if I try to defend or attack you don't get it the wrong way! At the end I know this is a game! I just like to play this way =) I enjoy it. You all know I love you all. <3
Okay, serious face now.
Okay, serious face now.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
What. This post, this right there. It's absolutely and completely illogical.
First of all, we have 4 guests and 4 people who have claimed guest, while everyone has claimed either PR or guest. Why on earth would the 4 be lying? Yes, you never know what may be going on in people's heads, but they would have absolutely no motive, none whatsoever to lie about their role.
Second, the part about letting the cop know: NO. You'll be giving the mafia the cop on a silver plate, ready to kill right on the second night. One investigation result is far too little to take that risk, especially when we don't know if the remaining cop is sane or paranoid.
And when you say you're not sure about notty and what not... It is clear to me that if either of you flips mafia, the other is mafia. It's classic "Oh, I don't know, maybe he's not guily after all" when a mafia member wants to steer everyone else clear of another mafia, but then doesn't want to stay suspicious, in case the other does get lynched in the end.
If either of you two gets lynched, I'm heading straight towards the next with my vote, if things continue the way they have been going so far.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who finds ansoro's posts to be extremely suspicious, I'm going to focus on notty for now.
notty put forward the plan to confirm the innocents, and as far as I'm concerned it could help both the mafia and town depending on how it's used. What really bothers me though... nottykitten keeps saying we're better off because we have confirmed innocents and not once actually using that in their logic. In fact in most of nottykittens arguments the fact we have confirmed innocents is ignored, in some ways this game is a race against the mafia and tbh both getting the innocents a no-lynching on the same day is the worst move we can make, it basically allows the mafia to use that to their advantage while not using the same opportunity we created for ourselves.
vote nottykitten because it feels like your ignoring the advantages we fought to create then letting scum use them to their advantages instead.
notty put forward the plan to confirm the innocents, and as far as I'm concerned it could help both the mafia and town depending on how it's used. What really bothers me though... nottykitten keeps saying we're better off because we have confirmed innocents and not once actually using that in their logic. In fact in most of nottykittens arguments the fact we have confirmed innocents is ignored, in some ways this game is a race against the mafia and tbh both getting the innocents a no-lynching on the same day is the worst move we can make, it basically allows the mafia to use that to their advantage while not using the same opportunity we created for ourselves.
vote nottykitten because it feels like your ignoring the advantages we fought to create then letting scum use them to their advantages instead.
Ansoro2112
Hottie
Yes, I agree with you. It would be very stupid for someone to lie about not being a Regular Guest or the other way around. Since that only affects us Town. Again, I just never trust anyone in this game and I'm always thinking the worse. But if later on someone did lied about it please remember me. <3
And I know the cop outting today is not the brightest idea. But I just don't want him/her to be killed next. It's me again thinking about the worst thing that can happen.
So for not voting for Notty I'm suspicious? I just don't find him guilty right now. That's me. And I don't like voting for someone if I'm not completely sure.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
That is because "we have 4 proven innocents" has no relation and can thus not be used as an argument for "we should No Lynch". I'm saying that have 4 proven innocents is an advantage we created, and also that No Lynching would be good to us.
Nonsense.
- Status