TBD [Status: GAME OVER]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
Mooglie
The Local Cow
Shoutout to my laptop who is dead/dying on me on not only Christmas, but Mafia and other stuff during this break \o/ You get an A*, laptop ( although it's doing fine as I'm typing this since I will not suffer typing this stuff on my tablet ;-; )
I'm a bit surprised at this beginning since most Day 0's, or Day 1 in this case, go: person explains why to lynch, person says we should no lynch, everyone no lynches, no conversations are had. (ok laptop has started mildly vibrating now, my time is short) I don't know what to think about the whole Hunter, Defiant, Myuser, Ltin, Duffie and Alpha situation atm since all look a tad scummy/are playing oddly atm. I think Duffie is less suspicious than the others (although still intriguing) and Hunter is playing like his normal, slightly aggressive, self in Mafia which seems okay I guess. Alpha I would expect to be some sort of fool role but apparently they're not in this game but, if they are the alien, I don't think they're the biggest threat to us atm since probing normally doesn't do anything but get them closer to their win condition and that will take a while from Day 1. Not sure where I stand with Ltin or Defiant since I haven't acted with them much in Mafia games before HOWEVERRRR myuser does look suspicious to me since I have acted alongside him in the Masquerade game where we were both Assassins and his playstyle here seems similar to that. Then again, I could be remembering incorrectly but he is my top FoS atm.
That's just my opinion though \o/
I'm a bit surprised at this beginning since most Day 0's, or Day 1 in this case, go: person explains why to lynch, person says we should no lynch, everyone no lynches, no conversations are had. (ok laptop has started mildly vibrating now, my time is short) I don't know what to think about the whole Hunter, Defiant, Myuser, Ltin, Duffie and Alpha situation atm since all look a tad scummy/are playing oddly atm. I think Duffie is less suspicious than the others (although still intriguing) and Hunter is playing like his normal, slightly aggressive, self in Mafia which seems okay I guess. Alpha I would expect to be some sort of fool role but apparently they're not in this game but, if they are the alien, I don't think they're the biggest threat to us atm since probing normally doesn't do anything but get them closer to their win condition and that will take a while from Day 1. Not sure where I stand with Ltin or Defiant since I haven't acted with them much in Mafia games before HOWEVERRRR myuser does look suspicious to me since I have acted alongside him in the Masquerade game where we were both Assassins and his playstyle here seems similar to that. Then again, I could be remembering incorrectly but he is my top FoS atm.
That's just my opinion though \o/
GmK
International Man Of Cake
Correct, that dabbles with PM mechanics for obvious reasons.
I should have clarified (my fault) that if a person had any pre-game communication, that that (the contents! Not the basic fact of course) cannot be part of discussion here, since we cannot ever use PM contents to confirm/deny things (but it of course adds certain relevant meta elements to the game!)
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Well these last 13 pages seem fishy.
To answer a question that had been asked to me on Page one:
I don't think we should be lynching Alpha. While I don't really believe Alpha's claim at all, I don't think lynching him is a good idea. From what I've read Alpha just randomly claimed Alien. He wasn't backed into a corner nor was he forced to claim. He could of easely said "I said I had amnesia not that I am an amnesiac" and be done with it. Though he chose to claim Alien instead. Which has to have a reason obviously. Now I don't think a Mafia would of done this. There were easier ways out than claiming alien. I think he is some other third Party role. One that like the alien, needs to do his action during the night to get closer to victory.
I myself don't really care what Third Party role this is, as long as he can't kill anyone or doesn't interfere with town business such as roleblocking town PR's or something. So Alpha102 would you like to revice your claim as Alien maybe or are you sticking with it x)? Since as long as you are no harm to the town, I don't see a reason for the town to lynch you if you claim something harmless. [which was your intention in the first place with claiming Alien]. I'd be amazed if you are actually an Alien but I highly doubt it.
The onto the third bit of my large post, the hunter/defiant situation. I think defiant has been playing fine so far. Nothing too scummy or anything. Although I do think that his vote on Alpha was rushy/bad, there isn't really anything else him atm.
Hunter however seems really Anti-town. Especialy this:
Vote Hunter27a1
To answer a question that had been asked to me on Page one:
I don't know you tell me! My name is Hercules, and I am the cop. I can investigate one person each night and claiming cop on day 1 is my strategy. I will not blow up when someone kills me during the night and I too, have Amnesia.
I don't think we should be lynching Alpha. While I don't really believe Alpha's claim at all, I don't think lynching him is a good idea. From what I've read Alpha just randomly claimed Alien. He wasn't backed into a corner nor was he forced to claim. He could of easely said "I said I had amnesia not that I am an amnesiac" and be done with it. Though he chose to claim Alien instead. Which has to have a reason obviously. Now I don't think a Mafia would of done this. There were easier ways out than claiming alien. I think he is some other third Party role. One that like the alien, needs to do his action during the night to get closer to victory.
I myself don't really care what Third Party role this is, as long as he can't kill anyone or doesn't interfere with town business such as roleblocking town PR's or something. So Alpha102 would you like to revice your claim as Alien maybe or are you sticking with it x)? Since as long as you are no harm to the town, I don't see a reason for the town to lynch you if you claim something harmless. [which was your intention in the first place with claiming Alien]. I'd be amazed if you are actually an Alien but I highly doubt it.
The onto the third bit of my large post, the hunter/defiant situation. I think defiant has been playing fine so far. Nothing too scummy or anything. Although I do think that his vote on Alpha was rushy/bad, there isn't really anything else him atm.
Hunter however seems really Anti-town. Especialy this:
You refuse to answer questions because Myuser might be a Lie-detector. Why? Got something to hide? If you're town why would you worry about people finding out if you're lying? Townspeople shouldn't be lying, thats what the anti-town usually do. And because of that I'll:
Vote Hunter27a1
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
I had a big post that's all deleted and asdfghjkl; I still have stuff to catch up on but I start work in less then 12 hours and I only just got off work so bleh. I'll repost tomorrow, hopefully.
Can we try to calm down a little bit because some of us can't always keep up with 10+ pages within 12 hours, basically. It's nice to have an active game with people actually posting and stuff but when it's like this it's just too much :/
Can we try to calm down a little bit because some of us can't always keep up with 10+ pages within 12 hours, basically. It's nice to have an active game with people actually posting and stuff but when it's like this it's just too much :/
Yes basically.
When you say this you imply you know that mafia knows who their partners are. The only way you can know this is if you are a mafia yourself.
Yea I suppose it is partially his playstyle.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
And here's where I hop in and say that sometimes townspeople should lie to save their own skin to be able to help the town at least a little bit later.
Actually, that same logic could be applied to the whole Alpha situation... as Jk seems to have pointed out already. ._.
unvote
Omgus much?
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
Glad to see that no one posted while I was catching up, made it easier <3
I don't quite see how that's suspicious. ._.
2. They're a possible team, seeing as I doubt he hasn't noticed that they're more or less teaming up.
3. To my knowledge, there aren't, but some people could be hiding it... Or it could be some crazy thing and we only find out during the night.
>don't lynch who could do such a thing to a poor innocent baby kitten?![/joking]
As of now, Hunter's basically my main FoS. It may be in part due to his playstyle, but said playstyle is rather erratic and I just can't really trust anything he says. And yes, refusing to answer a question because the asker may be a lie detector... Yeah, no.
Um, I'm pretty sure he was basically doing the same thing that I did, basically: "Don't kill me while I'm gone pls"
I don't quite see how that's suspicious. ._.
1. He felt he had no other option.
2. They're a possible team, seeing as I doubt he hasn't noticed that they're more or less teaming up.
3. To my knowledge, there aren't, but some people could be hiding it... Or it could be some crazy thing and we only find out during the night.
[joking]>legit kitten obvs
>don't lynch who could do such a thing to a poor innocent baby kitten?![/joking]
Exactly the wording I was looking for ty :3
As of now, Hunter's basically my main FoS. It may be in part due to his playstyle, but said playstyle is rather erratic and I just can't really trust anything he says. And yes, refusing to answer a question because the asker may be a lie detector... Yeah, no.
I've repeatedly said that I screwed up to get to this point, so mistakes have been made. After all this I don't think I can retract the claim so easily 
I will say that I'm playing against type, never been Alien before. I'm not really an expert at claiming, either.
My ideal situation would have been to have stayed quiet throughout most of the day, but I figured once Defiant_Blob called me out on the amnesiac thing there was no way out, so honestly looked like my best chance at the time. I didn't think I could get away with a boring town claim.
Nottykitten, care to elaborate on anything amnesiac related?
I will say that I'm playing against type, never been Alien before. I'm not really an expert at claiming, either.
My ideal situation would have been to have stayed quiet throughout most of the day, but I figured once Defiant_Blob called me out on the amnesiac thing there was no way out, so honestly looked like my best chance at the time. I didn't think I could get away with a boring town claim.
Nottykitten, care to elaborate on anything amnesiac related?
no, lyncher is a thirdparty role which defaults to townsided if the target dies by other means, and the target is always nonmafia
was more worried about voodoo-type roles and I did not want to encourage the obvious bluffing of "liedetectors"
I would like to remind you Hunter that this is not Epicmafia, for example a couple of the earlier seasons of mafia had the lyncher choose their target, which could be mafia.
The theory in general is a long shot, as right now it looks like a guess at Duffie's specific role in an attempt to clear yourself as town.
I will agree that Duffie is definitely hiding something though.
-
What Nottykitten said sounded like sarcasm to me, though I would really like some elaboration on the amnesiac part.
The theory in general is a long shot, as right now it looks like a guess at Duffie's specific role in an attempt to clear yourself as town.
I will agree that Duffie is definitely hiding something though.
-
What Nottykitten said sounded like sarcasm to me, though I would really like some elaboration on the amnesiac part.
Errrr... You're skipping the point entirely. So far the only people you've accused of being mafia or a non favorable third party role are people who disagree with you. Earlier, you even went so far as to lump everyone who disagreed with you together and suggest them as a mafia team. You and I know this is considered bad form and isn't necessarily a good scum hunting tactic either. So why so much omgus?
if a lyncher target was a mafia member, their goal would not be any different from being a normal townie, and would always win with town. they would have the advantage of knowing who a maf member was from the start.
myuser it's not the people who disagree with me it's the way they disagree with me. mostly suggesting possible teams, if mafia knows their partners. individually their actions can be scummy as well.
myuser it's not the people who disagree with me it's the way they disagree with me. mostly suggesting possible teams, if mafia knows their partners. individually their actions can be scummy as well.
Again, I was momentarily implying lie detector as a short term baiting strategy. I've already said I'm not a lie detector and the questions had nothing to do with my role. Tell you what, if I claim lie-detector at any point in this game feel free to lynch me, okay?