TBD [Status: GAME OVER]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
I just don't see why you don't want people answering the questions.
I guess I'll explain myself.
I guess I'll explain myself.
He is doing something odd. And we want to know peoples opinion on it. And if people don't think he's doing something odd then they say that in their answer.
No, it doesn't really. Atleast not how I see the question. He is simply describing the situation and asking peoples opinion about it. Because -> everyone did seem to think Myuser was defending Alpha alot.
If people can't even ask/answer questions anymore then what do you propose we do? Nothing at all...?
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
If you are voting someone, why are you voting this person?
I'm voting Hunter at the moment, because he just looks entirely too scummy to me. But it's also partly a 'policy' vote I guess, because his currently erratic playstyle could do more harm than good in the future.
I'm voting Hunter at the moment, because he just looks entirely too scummy to me. But it's also partly a 'policy' vote I guess, because his currently erratic playstyle could do more harm than good in the future.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
It didn't influence my answer, and I doubt it influenced yours. Only someone that hasn't been paying attention to whats going on at all will get influenced. And that's their own fault for not reading about the events themselves Iguess.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
I'm about to fall off my desk chair. I'm up to Enders large post on 25 and will continue on from there in the morning before I make myself sick from lack of sleep. I'm really sorry guys. I'll also answer questions and stuff and yeah
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Say what you want about Myuser's questions, but I changed the biased ones so that they didn't have an assumption in them and I feel like I gave perfectly good answers. Asking questions and answering them is a totally legitimate strategy which has proven useful more than once in my past games, so I think that asking questions and answering them is fine. What myuser did is introduce his own opinion into his questions (I'm willing to believe he did it by accident), and he realized that and we even came up with questions that were basically the same question, only without that opinion already built in them. So I propose that we answer those questions and move on from there.
Again, just eliminate the loaded part and we're totally good.
as in, statistically more likely to lynch a townie
I was the rough sleeper in supernatural and had the best death post
We should keep liars alive because they are liars? hahaha no
wifom+people would attack notty anyway and in fact are more likely to do so because of me typing this line, and notty would most likely flip out about me "ruining their plan". let's see what his "investigation" is tomorrow assuming he even gets one
agreeing with the first line and the part about third party claims being unquestioned, but you're defending someone based on the grounds of not trusting their claim
couldn't give less of a fuck
sorry, thought that was obvious
oh look another topic change coming up
have you seen the other games? I'm usually lynched because of being hard to read, and that screws over the rest of the game. It's practically tradition.
I'd consider town/not town to be more important than alignment. Non-townsided, win condition wise.
bingo
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Omg Hunter you ruined EVERYTHING how could you do this omg.
Pfft I dont "flip out" i casually get passive agressive. Either way I dont even have a plan except me claiming cop day 1 and seeing what happens, so there is nothing to ruin here.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Goodbye, never gonna expect any valid logic from you again. (before Alpha freaks out again, no, I'm not gonna quit, I just overdramatize to emphasize my point
)Your arguments have strawmen all over. What he said wasn't that we should keep liars alive because they are liars, what he said (or at least that's the impression I'm getting, and that's definitely the way I see things), was that we don't really have any idea whether Alpha is scum or not, since his claim felt so off that it seemed like it was intentionally made to be very flawed. That would mean that we have almost no way of telling if he's Alien or townie or mafia or whatever in this game, for all we know.
