The Red Scare [Game Over]
- Thread starter Ltin
- Start date
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
random lynching implies no suspicion, just bloodthirst, while pushing for a lynch generally means the person doing the pushing has at least a suspicion of some sort and probably some kind of evidence to back it up
he made exactly zero posts in three days and was tagged at least once in an attempt to get his attention
funny I've been getting the opposite
can we like,,, let this die I mean really
I'm not 100% sure I'm reading this right but well. Yes a townie is already dead, but you're also assuming the worst case scenario in which we lynch another townie, the doctor fails, and the vig hits a townie. All of those happening at once doesn't seem too likely. Possible but not certain. Also, you say IF the mafia kills--why would they not?
For the good of the town, if I die then I blame caff (although I'm not suspicious of them)!
I am suspicious at this moment in time of Notty, Unu & Samlen.
Notty due to irrational Voting pattern
Unu due to his long statements that don't give too much informations
Samlen because I would expect him to be an active member... but that has not really happened so far.
Would go into more detail but gotta go fast!
I admit on day 0 I voted Inf for bants because of his terrible joke. However, he was the only person to say that Hip was acting suspiciously and now Hip is dead. I'm saying my theory is he is mafia and thought Hip was a Town PR role and tried to get him lynched, but when that didn't go through he night killed Hip in the hopes of saving his heiny
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Once again I ask, if I thought hip was PR (why would I even think that, where is this even coming from what), why would I try to get him lynched (which would end in me being suspicious since I pushed on a town PR) instead of just waiting to night kill him? I swear you make no sense this game at all
Say for instance, Inffy thought that Hip was the Vigilante, that would mean that if Inf kept pushing for a lynch of Hip, he would get suspicious and night kill him. I could go into a whole Inffy rant of a 'I know Inf and I know that something's off' but in all honesty I've only played one game with Inf and in that game he died kinda quickly... I'm going to keep my vote on inf, but the more defensive Notty gets of Inf the more suspicious of her I am... I mean if Inf does get lynched and flip Maf you are going to be my number 1 suspicion
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
What you're saying is that you think Inf thought Hip to be the vigilante. Then you say 'that would mean that if Inf kept pushing for a lynch of Hip', Hip(as vig) would kill him.
The only logical conclusion to draw from this is that Inf did not think that Hip was the vig, because if he did why did Inf keep pushing for a Hip lynch untill the day ended? So now I repeat again, how does killing Hip save Inf again when according to your reasoning he could not have thought Hip to be the vig?
What?! How is that a logical conclusion? The more you talk Notty the more suspicious of you I become
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Foggy you are making no sense
You said that your theory is that I thought hip was vigilante and so I stopped pushing for a lynch so that they wouldn't nightkill me and so I'd nightkill them instead, but I didn't stop pushing for a hip lynch, so clearly that's not the case, and I mean even if it were, hip posted very little so why would I manage to figure out that he's the vigilante? I figured he was probably Mafia BECAUSE he spoke so little but to base a theory on me on the idea that I somehow figured hip's exact role from literal nothingness is surely ridiculous.
You said that your theory is that I thought hip was vigilante and so I stopped pushing for a lynch so that they wouldn't nightkill me and so I'd nightkill them instead, but I didn't stop pushing for a hip lynch, so clearly that's not the case, and I mean even if it were, hip posted very little so why would I manage to figure out that he's the vigilante? I figured he was probably Mafia BECAUSE he spoke so little but to base a theory on me on the idea that I somehow figured hip's exact role from literal nothingness is surely ridiculous.
Mhm, am I the only one who was really bothered by what TWG said earlier?
Could be some sort of preparation by mafia, to lynch Iggy the day after Inffy gets lynched. Overall I really don't find this a statement that a townie or a cautious mafia would make.
Then again, I am suspicious of both Iggy and Inffy at this moment, so I am not fully sure what to think of this yet. Some general feedback would be appreciated, or did we already move away from this bold statement?
Like, does the think we will blindly vote Iggy the moment, in theory, that Inffy is to get lynched and does turn out to be town after all?
Could be some sort of preparation by mafia, to lynch Iggy the day after Inffy gets lynched. Overall I really don't find this a statement that a townie or a cautious mafia would make.
Then again, I am suspicious of both Iggy and Inffy at this moment, so I am not fully sure what to think of this yet. Some general feedback would be appreciated, or did we already move away from this bold statement?
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
Is it just me who thinks foggy and inf could both be mafia?
Foggy seems very certain with his hypothesis that inf thought hip was vigilante, which tbh, does seem to have come from no where. To me it looks like foggy is overly determined to push for an inf lynch which makes me wonder if he knows something.
Foggy if you do know something about inf, if you are a cop role or something, would you mind sharing?
I never said that you stopped pushing for the lynch, just that it didn't go through.
^ It was an example using the Vig not saying that was the exact town PR you thought he was.
Whilst being mafia, getting rid of any town PR is the most beneficial course of action so I think you saw him as a threat 1) because you assumed he had a role of importance and 2) because he is our friend and would probably target you and find you out more easily and possibly target you if he was a position such as Vig.