Tavern Arcana - Mafia Win
- Thread starter Jolterino
- Start date
Wasn’t it quite obvious anyway?
Danni122112
The Drunk
Ooglie101 lie101
I would say we have a lot to go on in terms of mafia suspects, my prime Candidate is currently choco, but I would like to see what he has to say, this isn't day 0, we have info, even though you may not have all of it yourself.
Again, I'm not saying that Notty is innocent, I am personally 50/50, but she is claiming a power role, and you seem very eager to potentially lynch one of our power roles, WHEN YOU HAVE THE CHOSE TO BE SURE.
And please, respond to the rest of my arguments too ogle.
I would say we have a lot to go on in terms of mafia suspects, my prime Candidate is currently choco, but I would like to see what he has to say, this isn't day 0, we have info, even though you may not have all of it yourself.
Again, I'm not saying that Notty is innocent, I am personally 50/50, but she is claiming a power role, and you seem very eager to potentially lynch one of our power roles, WHEN YOU HAVE THE CHOSE TO BE SURE.
And please, respond to the rest of my arguments too ogle.
Danni122112
The Drunk
I am aware, the intent however is the same, but why not just wait til tomorrow, and while you say you have made the point, you act like you don't consider it an option.
Thoughts on choco?
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
yes but it might be because she literally is scummy and thus doesn't want to come off scummy later on?
It makes way more sense for scum to do it than what you did last game.
Danni122112
The Drunk
If we don't use what we have of the day, to see if we can find a good mafia suspect, that we can vote on, I'm leaving the fucking game.
I see no reason not to wait til tomorrow. None of you have tried giving a good reason either.
If we use day, and don't find any good suspect she, sure lynch Notty.
But just lynching Notty at the start of he day without trying to find other suspects, or use the day, screams mafia to me, or just stupid
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
The scummy one is you though.
Remind me again why you were talking about not caring AT ALL about who of the 3 lynch suspects are going to get lynched. I mean really, your argument is that somehow every single one of the 3 people is equally suspicious to you and you think the town is so good all 3 possible lynch suspects on day 0 are somehow anti-town. You didn't care since you're Mafia trash and you don't care who you lynch honestly
Danni122112
The Drunk
There is a fucking cop or a seer, there always is. Stop trying to pull out of your Ass that there isn't. Come with examples, please.
Cop killed in the night? So be it, kill Notty, nakes no difference.
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
Oh yes how scummy of me to spend all of day 0 trying to rally people to vote for 3 people, one of which has been confirmed antitown and the other 2 are todays 2 most voted.
And no I never said all 3 were equally suspicious, for most of it you were the most suspicious and I still would of preferred a lynch on you over anyone else day 0. I only changed up my votes because it didnt look like you were going to get lynched and choco and inf were ALSO suspicious in my eyes.
1. WE CANT KNOW IF WE HAVE A COP OR NOT. Even if you have played 3 games before this with a cop in every game, that doesn't mean we must have one now too. I agree that it's likely that we have a cop but we can't know for sure.
2. A smart cop wouldn't investigate Notty, why? Likely lynch target, if cop inspected notty it would be fucking idiotic to out himself to save Notty.
3. Her card is suspicious and hasn't brought any info so it's completely useless for Town, and she might not even have that role either.
4. We (almost) HAVE to lynch today, otherwise we would end up losing time, valuable time. Each night 2 players are killed, we can't really afford to nl (or even ml, but this is a chance we have to take).You seem to not want to lynch Notty, then maybe come with a lynch suggestion yourself?
5. Your argument that we are "tunnelvisisioning" Notty like we did with you last game (where you were town) is, first of, completely irrelevant, and secondly, wrong. Last game you claimed to be 3rd party! Not town, third party! In our role descriptions it was told that we needed to eliminate all threats to town (all non-town I assumed) and you claimed it, and naturally we lynched you(well tried at least). This is not at all like last game.
6. I'm not sure you have followed with us, but Notty claimed her role that A. Nobody can prove B. Could be entirely fictual C. She could make up all the events throughout the game, and probably the most important D. Claiming that the role will become more important later on (for events) so we wouldn't lynch a "PR".
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
YOU HAVE REACHED SAFE PARKING.
Congratulations on making it to day 1! It's been hectic so far so have a free space spot to rest while you prepare for the 10 pages you still have to read.
Here is your friendly non-biased tower speaking, and I would like to remind you that the vocal majority attacking me could easely be Mafia. I'm mostly talking about Aqua here and in reality the vocal minority defending me could also be Mafia but just consider that their opinions don't have to be yours!
Onwards you go!
Congratulations on making it to day 1! It's been hectic so far so have a free space spot to rest while you prepare for the 10 pages you still have to read.
Here is your friendly non-biased tower speaking, and I would like to remind you that the vocal majority attacking me could easely be Mafia. I'm mostly talking about Aqua here and in reality the vocal minority defending me could also be Mafia but just consider that their opinions don't have to be yours!
Onwards you go!