Tavern Arcana - Mafia Win

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
HES BEEN SO SCUMMY THE ENTIRE GAME HOW DID YOU NOT SEE THIS

Plus being 1-shot that doesn't sound believable at all. So far we've had no 1-shot abilities in this game and it doesn't make sense to have it unless they wanted to balance the town somehow but I don't see if there were a vigilante why it would be limited like that. He wanted to take credit for Infs dead but couldn't explain why I wasn't dead tonight so he lied and added 1-shot to his fake claim.

Also I guess we know he was the justice card but it would of been nice if there was actual confirmation he was scum
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
Decay spreads throughout Aqua’s body as they fall towards the ground, their hollowed face in a silent scream. You reach forward to pick up their card, but it is nowhere to be seen.

---


Day 2 continues, which will last 5 days. The deadline is at 1 PM GMT, 3 April. (Tuesday)
With 19 players alive, it takes 10 players to lynch and 10 players to no lynch.
If the required vote amount is not reached by the deadline, the player with the most votes will be lynched.​
well that's (un)fortunate
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
He knows he's been acting scummy all game so he wanted to make a believable claim by making everyone think he killed Inf n1 to make town think he was on their side. But if he were to claim vigilante people would ask why he didn't kill me last night, so he limited his role to '1-shot' to work around that which is extremely obvious + he's been scummy all game so he deserved to be shot
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
i still dont get why that makes it unbelievable its not like one shot vigilantes are rare
Because HES SCUM and one shot vigs are pretty rare and are only made to make sure the town isn't overpowered and since we've yet to see any other powerful ability roles(mine doesn't directly hurt the Mafia) I don't see why that would be in this setup and Aqua didn't think about that when he claimed.

But now that I've gotten rid of one extremely likely scum (two if you count Choco but honestly why did he not claim doctor), I'm not entirely sure who we should lynch yet.
 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
Because HES SCUM and one shot vigs are pretty rare and are only made to make sure the town isn't overpowered and since we've yet to see any other powerful ability roles(mine doesn't directly hurt the Mafia) I don't see why that would be in this setup and Aqua didn't think about that when he claimed.
oh you mean no other powerful ability roles
such as the one
that gave you a gun
that instantly killed a player

also guns make 0 sense in this setup so thats a 100% lie
it seems more of a magician thing ('decay spreads through the body' or whatever)
so i doubt notty even fired that at all and is just taking credit for a mafia/serial killer day kill
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
also guns make 0 sense in this setup so thats a 100% lie
it seems more of a magician thing ('decay spreads through the body' or whatever)
so i doubt notty even fired that at all and is just taking credit for a mafia/serial killer day kill
Gunsmith is decently powerful true but I meant more power as in ways to find out Mafia. Guns can still kill town people. Bless the gunsmith though since obviously they believed in me.

But where is his card? hmmmmm
Genuinly no idea I thought the gun was just a simple point and click thing like usual guns but we didn't get to see Aquas role and nothing was told to me so :thinking: maybe these all guns from the gunsmith won't actually reveal people?
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
Genuinly no idea I thought the gun was just a simple point and click thing like usual guns but we didn't get to see Aquas role and nothing was told to me so :thinking: maybe these all guns from the gunsmith won't actually reveal people?
My grammar is slowly dying unlike Aqua who died swiftly and quickly
 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
oh god i promised myself i wouldnt end up like you nerds going and analysing tarot cards online but here i am

MAGICIAN in general:

'The Magician’s robe is white, symbolising the purity and innocence found in the Fool but his cloak is red, representing worldly experience and knowledge. In the bed of flowers at his feet this duality is repeated in the mix of pure white lilies and thorny red roses.'

MAGICIAN upright:

'You have the ability to take the power of the Universe and manifest your desires. The Magician Tarot card suggests that a situation has been (or soon will be) presented to you that has all the inherent components to allow the manifestation of your desires. Those desires may be spiritual (fire), physical (earth), emotional (water), or mental (air), and are each aligned with the four elements of the Tarot. You have the ability to make it happen!'

'The Magician Tarot card is a good omen when you have a specific wish, when you begin a project involving creativity, or when you need to make a transformation of any kind. This is a great Tarot card for meditation when you need to call all the elements for help and wisdom.'

MAGICIAN upside down:

'Reversed, the Magician can indicate greed, deceit, manipulation and using one’s skill and ability for negative ends. It can reflect trickery and cunning, untrustworthiness and mental confusion.'

'You need to return to the lesson of the Fool and free yourself from the current situation in order to give yourself some perspective and reassess the situation'

-------

ok so i've obviously cherry picked quotes from only one website to support my point (i mean those quotes say like CREATIVITY and GOOD OMEN and PURITY within them as well)

i'd suggest that the magician is a gunsmith-esque role that can idk give a person like one-shot magic for the day which they can use CREATIVELY to MANIFEST THEIR DESIRES whether it be good or bad depending on who gets the magic
for example, last night they gave their magic to notty to use today who manifested their desires by killing aqua (and his card)

uh im not sure of what the alignment would be based on those abilities, it would be very OP in towns hands (you could give it to cop and be like BULLET PROOF VEST TONIGHT -then again it seems to be only a day thing so far-) but also OP in mafias (wow i want LYNCH IMMUNITY today or something) but as third party they would essentially become the kingmaker deciding who to give their perks to
i guess that if they were mafia it could easily be portrayed as a town role leading to easier claims for them (which is beneficial in a set-up that seems to hint that bad cards -> bad alignment possibly) + idk what sane town person would give notty magic

i also dont like how many times 'the fool' came up in that website so i bolded it in a few quotes so maybe the magician can only give the magic to the fool (notty) or something and then that leads to the fool being more easily lynched BUT that would seem like a very :thinking: role that would probably be voted off

but yeah THOSE ARE MY THOUGHTS
 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
btw im not suggesting that the magician claims I THINK WE SHOULD REALLY STOP CLAIMING FOR LITERALLY 0 REASON LOOK WHERE IT GOT CHOCO

and on the subject of claiming, i was thinking about this during night & surely a mass claim would render roob's role useless? which suggests that keeping our cards a secret is a beneficial thing for town & i didnt want to bring this up (since idk if the mafia is gonna pretend this is gonna happen now) but n1 the only people who died were inf (who claimed hermit) and hk (who claimed emperor) aka people who had revealed their card BUT aqua (i choose to believe he was a vig, not necessarily one shot) seemed to hint that he just killed inf by saying name (the whole need to kill people who claim card thing could possibly be a mafia-only handicap but would suggest mafia is OP which is a ??? rn) but then again aqua who just died had claimed his card so WHO KNOWS

also that would mean that it is possible to reach a point where nobody had claimed = no night kills so PROBABLY not the case but who knows
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
and on the subject of claiming, i was thinking about this during night & surely a mass claim would render roob's role useless? which suggests that keeping our cards a secret is a beneficial thing for town & i didnt want to bring this up (since idk if the mafia is gonna pretend this is gonna happen now) but n1 the only people who died were inf (who claimed hermit) and hk (who claimed emperor) aka people who had revealed their card BUT aqua (i choose to believe he was a vig, not necessarily one shot) seemed to hint that he just killed inf by saying name (the whole need to kill people who claim card thing could possibly be a mafia-only handicap but would suggest mafia is OP which is a ??? rn) but then again aqua who just died had claimed his card so WHO KNOWS
Ohno but they know my card and also that sounds like a far-fetched theory.

So do we... not lynch Ender?
 

Roobarb Pie

Geezuslike
Donor
Contributor
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,148
btw im not suggesting that the magician claims I THINK WE SHOULD REALLY STOP CLAIMING FOR LITERALLY 0 REASON LOOK WHERE IT GOT CHOCO

and on the subject of claiming, i was thinking about this during night & surely a mass claim would render roob's role useless? which suggests that keeping our cards a secret is a beneficial thing for town & i didnt want to bring this up (since idk if the mafia is gonna pretend this is gonna happen now) but n1 the only people who died were inf (who claimed hermit) and hk (who claimed emperor) aka people who had revealed their card BUT aqua (i choose to believe he was a vig, not necessarily one shot) seemed to hint that he just killed inf by saying name (the whole need to kill people who claim card thing could possibly be a mafia-only handicap but would suggest mafia is OP which is a ??? rn) but then again aqua who just died had claimed his card so WHO KNOWS

also that would mean that it is possible to reach a point where nobody had claimed = no night kills so PROBABLY not the case but who knows
I'll be around to confirm their role that they stated. If two people are claiming the same role I can find out which one's lying.
 
Top