Tavern Arcana - Mafia Win

[Iggish]

No mafias have revealed watcher yet????

Fuck, sorry, I thought Arelic was a watcher.

 

[Danni122112]

Also, he could've said that as he deciphered your hints about being a cop and so wanted no negative association with you when you died or he tried to kill you.

I don’t understand what you are saying here.

 

[Unusual_Dood]

Fuck, sorry, I thought Arelic was a watcher.

Or this was a slip, since Arelic isn't even playing

 

[Danni122112]

I don’t think I will type too much here, I am mostly waiting on Dess, and what he thinks.

Also very interested in what ender five has to say.

My user/Unu/TWG, will happily discuss with you, or answer anything.

 

[TheWeakGuy48_]

TWG could you explain this? It seems to contradict quite a bit with what you were saying earlier today:

If you suspected him of being cop, then why did you say "Why he would wait with claiming his role feels odd to me"? This would just draw unwanted attention to someone who you suspected of being a cop?

I didn't push for Danni to claim. I just noted how it was weird how he hadn't claimed yet. I had no proof that he was cop, for all I knew, Ooglie could've been cop. I couldn't even say it directly, because "hey guys I think danni might be a cop" would've gotten the attention of the mafia and Danni might've been killed during the night.
I'm going to be honest here, if Danni had claimed any role other than cop (after, and maybe before, Ooglie died) I would've voted him.

 

[Iggish]

as I have been a bit suspicious of him all game

I don't remember you saying this.

 

[Danni122112]

Unusual_Dood
Would you mind typing out your entire role again?

 

[Iggish]

and he has been my main suspect for mafia today.

Why?

 

[Danni122112]

I don't remember you saying this.

You ain’t wrong, mostly just been trying to read you all game.

 

[Danni122112]

Why?

I think the way you just wanted to lynch ender was scummy. (This is a bs argument, I’m aware, you don’t have to reply to it)
There are you, my username, and UNU that I have not confirmed yet, I find you to be the most suspicious of the bunch.
I am sure Enderfive can explain it better
Ender voting for you was the final straw that tipped me over in wanting to kill you

 

[Iggish]

You can’t believe anything 100% in mafia.

What kind of crappy answer is that?

You have only tried to throw shade on my actions, you have however not tried to explain why there should not be a cop in the game. We have pretty solid proof that there is a cop in the game.

I said that Mulb's godfather ability could make them show up as another tarot card. This would eliminate the need for the cop as it would be dess' role.

I am very surprised you have not tried to claim cop yourself to stop my claim.

Why on Earth would I do that? I have been confirmed messenger by 4 different people.

 

[Iggish]

I don’t understand what you are saying here.

If you died, he would look more innocent as he town read you. That's basically what I'm saying. Sorry, I was in the bath on my phone. Back on my laptop now though.

 

[Danni122112]

The room closes in on Mulbery and puts them in a noose. The card that falls out of their hand is The Devil.

Spoiler: The Devil

Win Condition: Living Mafia players make up half or more of the living players without any possible threats
> Passive:
Alignment appears as town to any investigative roles
Has the final say on Mafia Night Kill

Iggish specifically states alignment, not card.

 

[Unusual_Dood]

My short plan is this:
Lynch iggish today
We both pray to god that iggish is mafia.
If iggish flips mafia, you will be lynched tomorrow.
You kill whoever you find most likely mafia.

I agree with lynching Iggish and if he is mafia then Ender, but I don't think he should use his kill ability if he isn't lying about it.

So, if there are 2 mafias I would prefer this to happen:

(2 mafs, 4 townies, 1 fool)
1. Day 5 - we lynch Iggish

If Iggish is mafia:
(1 maf, 3 townies, 1 fool)
2. Day 6 - we lynch Ender
Ender choose to not use his kill (if he has)

(1 maf, 2 townies)
3. Day 7 - we lynch either me or myuser

If Iggish is town, we skip 2. and hope that there only is 1 mafia left.

 

[Danni122112]

If you died, he would look more innocent as he town read you. That's basically what I'm saying. Sorry, I was in the bath on my phone. Back on my laptop now though.

I mean ok, so you get that what you are saying here is that when I flip town, he would appear innocent? I mean you ain’t wrong, but you just argued for me being town LOL

 

[Iggish]

Or this was a slip, since Arelic isn't even playing

Yeah, sorry. I just saw Arelic's name and went on autopilot. Looking back at all the mafias, I know all their roles so idk why I thought there was a watcher. I guess I just didn't make the mental connection of 4 dead mafias and 4 mafia roles I know.

Idk how it would be a slip though.

 

[Iggish]

I didn't push for Danni to claim. I just noted how it was weird how he hadn't claimed yet. I had no proof that he was cop, for all I knew, Ooglie could've been cop. I couldn't even say it directly, because "hey guys I think danni might be a cop" would've gotten the attention of the mafia and Danni might've been killed during the night.
I'm going to be honest here, if Danni had claimed any role other than cop (after, and maybe before, Ooglie died) I would've voted him.

So basically, you brought attention to the fact that it was strange that Danni hadn't claimed yet, but you thought he could be a cop as well? Idk how that is supposed to be productive at all.

 

[Danni122112]

What kind of crappy answer is that?

There is very rarely something you can trust 100% in mafia, except the roles from dead players. Even my investigations were not 100% due to it being a god father role.

 

[Iggish]

I think the way you just wanted to lynch ender was scummy. (This is a bs argument, I’m aware, you don’t have to reply to it)

Then why are you using it as justification for finding me scummy? wut?

There are you, my username, and UNU that I have not confirmed yet, I find you to be the most suspicious of the bunch.
I am sure Enderfive can explain it better
Ender voting for you was the final straw that tipped me over in wanting to kill you

Thanks for answering I guess? Although you haven't mentioned anything that I have done that has been suspicious? You think I'm "90% mafia" and haven't given any justification?

Why did you find me the most suspicious of the bunch?

 

[Danni122112]

So basically, you brought attention to the fact that it was strange that Danni hadn't claimed yet, but you thought he could be a cop as well? Idk how that is supposed to be productive at all.

He found it strange that I had not claimed, unless I was Cop, but he wasn’t sure if I was Cop. If I had claimed anything else than cop he would have lynched me.

 

[Iggish]

Iggish specifically states alignment, not card.

Hm, ok.

 

[Unusual_Dood]

Idk how it would be a slip though.

Myuser said he was a watcher. If you are mafia it is possible you are on team with myuser and forgot he wasn't dead or that the watcher role wasn't revealed yet.

 

[Danni122112]

I agree with lynching Iggish and if he is mafia then Ender, but I don't think he should use his kill ability if he isn't lying about it.

So, if there are 2 mafias I would prefer this to happen:

(2 mafs, 4 townies, 1 fool)
1. Day 5 - we lynch Iggish

If Iggish is mafia:
(1 maf, 3 townies, 1 fool)
2. Day 6 - we lynch Ender
Ender choose to not use his kill (if he has)

(1 maf, 2 townies)
3. Day 7 - we lynch either me or myuser

If Iggish is town, we skip 2. and hope that there only is 1 mafia left.

I will be trying to make a proper plan out of this later today, Sorry for not responding now.

 

[Iggish]

I mean ok, so you get that what you are saying here is that when I flip town, he would appear innocent? I mean you ain’t wrong, but you just argued for me being town LOL

Omg, my arguments are all over the place rn. Sorry, disregard that one then. The other Roob theories still stand though. he wanted people to trust you like they trusted him. By affiliation with roob.

 

[Iggish]

There is very rarely something you can trust 100% in mafia, except the roles from dead players. Even my investigations were not 100% due to it being a god father role.

My question was if you think that everyone believes that you are telling the truth.