Republic - Completed

[Infected_alien8_]

Spoiler

anyway i feel like not much of value has been said in the last few pages

elect: Hunter, Faliara, Velzerat, Nottykitten, Enderfive

i townread notty even though we disagree pretty strongly on what the right strategy is (but in saying that i don't like how inf is playing). enderfive has been towntelling fairly similarly although less so imo. i think they're good picks as if something new comes up in the council/we end up in democracy, they're viable lynch targets

So you town-read notty but consider her a viable lynch target?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

and ender*

 

[Jivvi]

So you town-read notty but consider her a viable lynch target?

i think they're good picks as if something new comes up in the council/we end up in democracy, they're viable lynch targets

they're not confirmed & while i townread them i don't think it's unlikely for that to due to something they say or new info coming to light

 

[Infected_alien8_]

they're not confirmed & while i townread them i don't think it's unlikely for that to due to something they say or new info coming to light

What does "for that to due to something" mean? I'm tired and I can't work out what you're trying to say

And why does the possibility of 'new info making them mafia', which applies to literally everyone, make notty and ender any more viable than anyone else?

 

[Hunter]

Jivvi why not replace notty w/inf in your vote
ender won't even get on the council at this rate b/c they're 1 vote behind notty

 

[Hunter]

*inf as a more viable lynch target

 

[Jivvi]

for that to due to

for that to change due to*

 

[Jivvi]

Jivvi why not replace notty w/inf in your vote
ender won't even get on the council at this rate b/c they're 1 vote behind notty

cause i'm scumreading inf a lot harder and he's also guaranteed to make council discussions a million times more complicated

 

[Infected_alien8_]

But jivvi

And why does the possibility of 'new info making them mafia', which applies to literally everyone, make notty and ender any more viable than anyone else?

 

[Jivvi]

And why does the possibility of 'new info making them mafia', which applies to literally everyone, make notty and ender any more viable than anyone else?

cause they're good players and if one of them slips up and one of the others catches is that's quite valuable

i don't have an overwhelming amount of reasoning for this since there's really not a great deal of thinking that can be done amount the remaining two slots since we've already established a town majority in the council (although i did forget we plan on going into autocracy in which case town players would be preferable; doesn't really change my thoughts though since i tr both of them).

 

[One one two]

Elect: Hunter, Faliara, One one two, Fog, myusername22

 

[Hunter]

cause i'm scumreading inf a lot harder and he's also guaranteed to make council discussions a million times more complicated

i just want inf on council so he can be lynched tomorrow tbh

 

[Jivvi]

i really don't get why you're hung up on this unless you yourself are particularly keen on being in the council. while my first post was a little poorly phrased (just woken up), i haven't voted anyone that hasn't been voted yet and i haven't seen you chase up others for the same thing.

i just want inf on council so he can be lynched tomorrow tbh

mood

 

[Jivvi]

i have about 12 confused ratings from inf now which is great cause now he knows how everyone else feels the rest of the time

 

[Infected_alien8_]

i really don't get why you're hung up on this unless you yourself are particularly keen on being in the council. while my first post was a little poorly phrased (just woken up), i haven't voted anyone that hasn't been voted yet and i haven't seen you chase up others for the same thing.

Because if your reason doesn't make sense (which it doesn't seem to) then I wonder whether it's because it isn't your true reason and there's something going on underneath

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Like why do you consider town-reads who would be good to lynch if they somehow turn out to be scum, more viable lynch targets than scumreads or people you don't have a town-read on

 

[Infected_alien8_]

i just want inf on council so he can be lynched tomorrow tbh

If you make a democracy you're going to be throwing the game

 

[Jivvi]

Because if your reason doesn't make sense (which it doesn't seem to) then I wonder whether it's because it isn't your true reason and there's something going on underneath

the way i see it:

3 town on council for majority

2 slots left

we don't know any mafia but we want autocracy so a 5 town council is fine

i vote 2 towntelling players because if there are mafia in the council they'll know the dictator

if council fucks it up and we get democracy, council members might be able to point fingers

if the dictator or a member of the council who turns out to be the doctor or watcher dies, we can probably assume that there was a mafia in the council and go from there

ender and notty are good targets because finding a skilled mafia member > finding a useless mafia member

 

[Jivvi]

Like why do you consider town-reads who would be good to lynch if they somehow turn out to be scum, more viable lynch targets than scumreads or people you don't have a town-read on

what

a) you're ignoring that mafia will know who the dictator is if they're on the council so we want 5 town members to go into autocracy
b) as i said in that^ post, if something gets fucked around or mafia knows the dictator, we can possibly pin a skilled player as mafia

 

[Infected_alien8_]

if the dictator or a member of the council who turns out to be the doctor or watcher dies, we can probably assume that there was a mafia in the council and go from there

Why?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

what

a) you're ignoring that mafia will know who the dictator is if they're on the council so we want 5 town members to go into autocracy
b) as i said in that^ post, if something gets fucked around or mafia knows the dictator, we can possibly pin a skilled player as mafia

a) I'm not ignoring it, you didn't include that in your explanation so it didn't seem to factor in on your decision
b) okay, I guess that makes sense, and I'm guessing that's what you meant when you said about the doc/watcher dying (as in the mafia bus-driver + granny'd the dictator) but the watcher wouldn't die in that scenario since they aren't affected by driver, so is that what you were referring to and you just forgot about that, or am I misunderstanding you completely

 

[Jivvi]

Why?

mafia knows dictator:
- if a watcher or doc is on the council, they will likely target the dictator
- mafia swaps them onto granny

although i just realised i forgot that a) watched doesn't die to granny and b) mafia probably won't kill the dictator directly (although rev might)

 

[Infected_alien8_]

b) mafia probably won't kill the dictator directly (although rev might)

What does Mafia not killing dictator directly have anything to do with what you just said?

 

[Jivvi]

What does Mafia not killing dictator directly have anything to do with what you just said?

i was thinking that if mafia knew dictator, they would just target them with night kill idk how that was vague

 

[Infected_alien8_]

i was thinking that if mafia knew dictator, they would just target them with night kill idk how that was vague

But your point was that they'd bus-drive them, not night kill them

I swear you're either not making any sense or I'm just too tired to think straight