MEDIEVAL MAFIA: INTRUSION [DAY 8]

[Nottykitten]

In my eyes it isn't really "giving up". So I could claim cop and you would all slap me in the face for "giving up" for revealing my role? He had a few votes on him and it was most likely that he would be lynched. The only thing he could have done was claim a role. And maybe he thought that people would actually stop voting him because he is the freelancer. Since freelancer could be good for the town.

 

[GmK]

If you die, your role gets outed. And then we would know your and thus Nitasu's role.

Yes, but once again (apart from nobody thinking of that in the situation, including myself, it might have changed things), in order for us to turn him into a confirmed towny we would have had to lynch me to prove it. So during that day, we would have lost one town and gained one confirmed one, leaving town not one bit better off: day is our only chance to hunt and lynch scum, we'd have given up that chance by making a point. And scum could have then just continued to kill nitasu, leaving town with two less by then confirmed townies...

 

[GmK]

Nottykitten - the difference is inbetween claiming "I claim and we can use that to our favor" and giving up "ok I dont care anymore, this is my role, do what you want". Remember shiny just saying "I'm the sk, fuck it".

 

[Nottykitten]

If you die, your role gets outed. And then we would know your and thus Nitasu's role.

Yes, but once again (apart from nobody thinking of that in the situation, including myself, it might have changed things), in order for us to turn him into a confirmed towny we would have had to lynch me to prove it. So during that day, we would have lost one town and gained one confirmed one, leaving town not one bit better off: day is our only chance to hunt and lynch scum, we'd have given up that chance by making a point. And scum could have then just continued to kill nitasu, leaving town with two less by then confirmed townies...

Hmm, I guess you're right about that. It would give the mafia another night to kill even though we get a confimed towny.

I'm gonna keep my vote on you for now, since I still think something about it wasn't entirely right. But I guess I'm less suspicious of you now then before.

 

[myusername22]

Hmm, I guess you're right about that. It would give the mafia another night to kill even though we get a confimed towny.

I'm gonna keep my vote on you for now, since I still think something about it wasn't entirely right. But I guess I'm less suspicious of you now then before.

Think about this for a moment even if he is towny do you want gmk playing the role or nitasu? Given the way both of them have been playing so far. I think were better off with gmk and I think gmk feels this way too (I'm assuming innocent only for sake of the argument being that this would be a normal action on any side. For all I know he could still be scum.

 

[Nottykitten]

Hmm, I guess you're right about that. It would give the mafia another night to kill even though we get a confimed towny.

I'm gonna keep my vote on you for now, since I still think something about it wasn't entirely right. But I guess I'm less suspicious of you now then before.

Think about this for a moment even if he is towny do you want gmk playing the role or nitasu? Given the way both of them have been playing so far. I think were better off with gmk and I think gmk feels this way too (I'm assuming innocent only for sake of the argument being that this would be a normal action on any side. For all I know he could still be scum.

If I were going on experience, yes I'd want GmK. But GmK wouldn't be confirmed that role while Nitasu would have been if GmK were dead. Atleast we knew we could trust Nitasu then.

 

[The Road to Ruin]

i had no idea. i had planned on doing something, but i couldnt think of anything.

SO STOP ASKING

 

[Jivvi]

Ahhhh, now I see: If upon death I had shown as Town, people would now know Nitasu is confirmed town. I simply didnt think of that.

That doesnt change the fact still that this would only have been possible due to Nitasu breaking the giving up rule

But if you were targeted, it would be easy for the spy to pull their abaility

 

[cooliorules]

If we did have that confirmed towny, I would probably suggest that mafia would kill them at night? I'm not sure, that's just my guess. May be completely wrong, but I wouldn't be at all surprised if that happened.

I'll give the reasoning too because otherwise I'll get called out as maf.
So basically, we have a confirmed town. Great! We can at least count on the fact that they'll be innocent. But the mafia will kill them, so we wouldn't have that confirmed person any longer.
This honestly did sound better in my head..

 

[Ltin]

Makes perfect sense. Now stop giving the mafia any ideas

 

[cooliorules]

We don't have the confirmed inno, so they can't do that anyway?

 

[Ltin]

We have to confirm someone eventually. Other wise winning will be very hard

 

[cooliorules]

Okay I'm just saying, that isn't that normal mafia logic..? I haven't played many games like this one, so I'm just sort of assuming what they would

 

[Jivvi]

Makes perfect sense. Now stop giving the mafia any ideas

or maybe it's just general knowledge that the mafia will likely already know, but was pointing out for yours and others' sakes?

 

[cooliorules]

Okay I'm just saying, that isn't that normal mafia logic..? I haven't played many games like this one, so I'm just sort of assuming what they would

Makes perfect sense. Now stop giving the mafia any ideas

or maybe it's just general knowledge that the mafia will likely already know, but was pointing out for yours and others' sakes?

Great minds think alike? o:
But yes. It's general knowledge. We don't even have that confirmed townie so what I was stating wouldn't work, anyway.

 

[Jivvi]

Honestly, Ltin, what you're doing now just seems to be a desperate gambit to throw suspicion off on anyone.

 

[cooliorules]

That's what I was thinking, Jivvi.
He seems to be trying to pin anything to anyone else, in an attempt to make himself look not guilty.
This is in no way trying to get that suspicion from him off me, just my opinion

 

[Ltin]

Jeeze, it was a joke.
If I wanted to thrpw suspicion on anyone, I would have a clear target.
marskid, vote count?

 

[MarsKid]

VOTECOUNT!!!
-Ltin = 2(Da Jinks, Hunter27a1) (L-13)
-GmK = 1(Nottykitten) (L-14)
-Alpha102 = 1(the road to ruin) (L-14)

With 29 players, takes 15 to lynch.

 

[cooliorules]

I'll think about the past events and if I think of anything will look into it in the morning and post it! I'm off to bed now though.
Also a lot I will say I'm going to bed. It's how I got suspicion last time, so don't want it to happen again.

 

[GmK]

*bows down* master Prizyms, Reader of minds!
I have been suspicious of you, dont lie to me

Sorry Ltin, I've just re-read the last 5 pages, and all you've been doing is cause confusion, getting extremely defensive and sarcastic when people actually try to question your reasons.

Now you've all of a sudden taken the "It was just a joke, k, ignore me" stance.

I'm not sure if this warrants a vote yet, but I also can't say if it's good for the game how you play.

 

[GmK]

Also, I am wondering if Prince Zacharais has been active already during this day and investigated.

If he has and discovered scum, I'll have to re-read the thread yet again looking for someone trying to leave hints as to whom to lynch, or the other way round: Who could be safe.

I'll also have to ponder on the Hangman role, all the hangman would want is for a certain player to get lynched. Nottykitten you were the one pushing hard for making me suspicious, I do wonder if you might have other motives than purely hunting scum

 

[GmK]

MarsKid

Can you do us a favor and post a final vote count in the lynch post? That makes following who ended up voting for whom much easier when looking at past days.

Thanks <3

 

[MarsKid]

Yeah sorry, I should have done that.

The original post was edited, but I'll copy the results here (names are in order of who voted first to who voted last)

Nitasu = 16(Alpha102, Sploorky, endersteve5, Prizyms, the road to ruin, Ooglie101, Hunter27a1, Thymos, Jivvi, GmK, ansoro2112, Ltin, Pim, std1997, HypeBurst, Da Jinks, cooliorules)

 

[myusername22]

I agree with gmk Ltin has been playing oddly and I'm getting a bad feeling on him. Usually my feelings Are biased because I'm getting overly suspicious of someone but in this case I've had little interaction and have an odd feeling on him now. Not to mention the fact he just says he was just "joking" this feels like he's afraid people are catching onto him and is an overreacting yet desperate attempt to convince people he is innocent. I'm not going to start a vote at this point but he is quite suspicious.