Uhm, Day 0 nolynch was voted for by most after hey'd had their fill of the day. If we ran out the whole day we probably would have ended up with a failed scumhunt lynch. I fail to see what a mafia would gain from ensuring that a townie isn't lynched. (There was a super low chance of us hitting anything other than a townie).
The Bloody Masquerade Ball [GAME OVER]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
There was a low chance, but a chance is a chance. The day is about the only time a Mafia dies. If we No Lynch, there is 0 chance a mafia dies during the day and they have a night to freely kill whomever they want.
Yeah, but we had zero evidence to go off.
Also, Notty was backed up profoundly once she produced unrelated evidence relating someones roleplay to their role. Meanwhile I'm here being mobbed for enforcing an opinion with evidence behind it.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
There was lots of evidence linking his roleplay to his role. He just had the misfortune of choosing to roleplay an Assasin while there is an Assasins Guild in the game and the Assassins have Assassin names as their role. Anyhow that is a discussion of yesterday x).
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
I've been looking through Ltin's posts. And many, many one-liners and weird stataments later I've come to the conclusion that Ltin is very suspicious.
Most of his posts are either:
- Telling me to not point out every mistake.
- Try and stop people from talking/figuring things out[the Nitasu code thingy amongst others]
- Generally not contributing much to the discussion.
And then ofcourse his agressiveness is quite annoying and suspicious. I mean, take this post:
And then when I stop talking about it because Nitasu is dead, I explained it tons of times right now and it happened yesterday, I suddenly have to keep talking about it or else I am suspicious according to his latest post:
Most of his posts are either:
- Telling me to not point out every mistake.
- Try and stop people from talking/figuring things out[the Nitasu code thingy amongst others]
- Generally not contributing much to the discussion.
And then ofcourse his agressiveness is quite annoying and suspicious. I mean, take this post:
-> telling me to stop explaining why Nitasu and his roleplay are related.
And then when I stop talking about it because Nitasu is dead, I explained it tons of times right now and it happened yesterday, I suddenly have to keep talking about it or else I am suspicious according to his latest post:
Vote Ltin
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
He didn't tell me to stop talking about it before, and now after it doesn't really matter anymore wants me to continue talking about it. Thats you.
People who were undecided? Could you please explain, I don't understand what you mean with that x).
My guess is that Notty spotted the Assassin's Creed reference and went from there to try and persecute Nita.
Then, if the above is true, that identifies Tim as a probably fake cop, unless Notty is a Godfather (Godmother?)
This also leaves Std in a highly suspicous light, due to Tim also inno-ing him.
Then, if the above is true, that identifies Tim as a probably fake cop, unless Notty is a Godfather (Godmother?)
This also leaves Std in a highly suspicous light, due to Tim also inno-ing him.
To extend this particular senetnce into more detail, why would you go to the effort of using a well-known character simply to prove somebody wrong.
More to the point, why would you choose the name of an assassin if you yourself were an assassin.
Nita wasn't ignorant to the fact that names could lead to role discoveries, as GmK stated multiple times that it would be unwise to reveal your given name
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Please state the discussion I was shrugging off, since I think you and I have an entirely different view of what that discussion was.
It surely does not help the town in any way. If anything it's bad for the town. And anything bad for the town is good for scum.
Nope, these are the people that voted No Lynch on day 0:
No-Lynch - 13 - digitalmez Mmarz11 timdood3 std1997 Prizyms Jivvi nitasu987 nottykitten Ltin Fiestaguy HypeBurst Duffie Alpha102
What my argument was, is that Nitasu didn't choose the Assassin name, but that he took his rolename to also roleplay. And because we knew that the rolename of the Assassin Guild's members were also Assassin Creed characters, Nitasu would of been a member if he chose his rolename to roleplay. And I thought that happened which is why i lead the vote on him. However it turns out he did indeed choose the roleplay name himself and didn't use his rolename for that.
The whole argument came down to wether you thought he used his rolename to RP or not. If he did, he was an Assassin. If not, he was not.
Sploorky
Member
Hm. I'm going to make an assumption, that with a town-sided watcher, there is also a town-sided tracker. This does not mean it is true, but it is likely, and knowing that the two roles often go together, I'm going to take an educated guess and say that this game, they do. As such, @std1997, consider yourself still untrustworthy in my eyes, but due to the fact there has been no cc's, I will not attempt to lynch you today. Timdood's clear has to be taken with a grain of salt, because I don't believe role claims until there are real backings to them.
@Jivvi I read it over, and you're right in what you say. I don't view you suspicious for doubting the cop claim, believing any claim that is given to you in a closed setup game is a very bad idea. As such, I would have natural suspicion on those who jump on Jivvi for this, but not me, eg @Alpha102 who has not said anything about the fact I(or JKangaroo apperently, but I won't speak for him) agree that the cop claim can not be fully trusted.
@Jivvi I read it over, and you're right in what you say. I don't view you suspicious for doubting the cop claim, believing any claim that is given to you in a closed setup game is a very bad idea. As such, I would have natural suspicion on those who jump on Jivvi for this, but not me, eg @Alpha102 who has not said anything about the fact I(or JKangaroo apperently, but I won't speak for him) agree that the cop claim can not be fully trusted.
I thought that there was somebody else wuth the same argument, but I forgot at the time. JK's huge pile of logic showing how Std is quite possibly mafia shouldn't be ignored. (I get the feeling that some of you tl;dr a lot of this)
GmK
International Man Of Cake
std1997 - 1 - 77_is_the_best (Lynch in 10)
Ltin - 1 - nottykitten (Lynch in 10)
Not voting:
xXxFruitNinjaxXx, myusername22, storm886, digitalmez, Fiestaguy, Mmarz11, Jivvi, Duffie, UltimateBudgie, timdood3, std1997, Sploorky, Old_Man_Oak_63, Prizyms, JKangaroo, Alpha102, Ooglie101, Ltin
With 20 alive, it takes 11 to lynch and 10 to no-lynch.
Deadline of day: None set yet
Also, Notty, I find it odd that you aren't really attacking me any more either, but rather Ltin (another person with similar doubts to myself and Sploorky). This leads me to think that you are targeting players that are slightly less well equipped to defend themselves against a full assault of suspicion. This would also explain you ignoring Sploorky and JK and instead tunneling me for my logic.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
That what you quoted was me and Jivvi talking about wether the Roleplay name and Rolename were actual evidence or not. Considering that was the entire conversation of yesterday, I don't see how it is suspicious if I don't want to continue talking about it. I mean, Nitasu is dead. We've stated the argument tons of times now. Do you really want me to keep talking about it? If you want to see why I voted nitasu go re-read it. It was the discussion of yesterday as I stated and I am not going to keep repeating the answer.
I've actually noticed that as a trend recently, not just Notty but in general. Maybe that could be the reason town is on a losing streak, because going after players that are skilled with arguments is much harder.