Trouble in the West: Pirates vs Cowboys [Finished]
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
- Status
Fiestaguy
The man with 8 fingers.
Let's just add: If you do not have an item state 'I do not have an item' to make it clear
Let's just say ONLY say you have an item if you have Received it. disclosing What item you have is your choice.
I do not have an item
@Jivvi. For the record. Care to state one of the two? :3
I don't have an item, but don't push it out of people. We don't want some important role outing with some halfdecent item and getting killed just for having the item.
Maybe include the rest of my post.
Please note that you will quite likely be exposing yourself by claiming to have an item If you are a vital role, or your item is a not a vest or a similar self-protective item, it may be best not to claim.
I, myself, do not possess any items.
Also, Fiesta, you are either being massively careless with your actions as of now, or you're trying to undermine the town. I suppose as this is the exact same thing you did last game, there's no big change here. Try to be careful with how you handle things, your logic thus far has been as watertight as a sieve.
Fiestaguy
The man with 8 fingers.
That is why i'm saying. It is for your own decision to say how good the item is.
So please say if you have an item or not. You can say
I have an item
I do not have an item
I wish not to disclose
as Jivvi said:
"Please note that you will quite likely be exposing yourself by claiming to have an item If you are a vital role, or your item is a not a vest or a similar self-protective item, it may be best not to claim."
Furthermore
It is your own decision if you want to disclose What item you posess
Item claim list
No item: (2) Jivvi, Fiestaguy
Item:
Not telling:
Still to claim item: (17)
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
I'm not telling and I hope others do the same. Unless you're about to get lynched, there is absolutely no reason to claim a role or an item, because it only gives the mafia a better idea who to kill during the night.
This is even worse. Not only will said person be showing that they have an item, they will be blatantly stating that it's something fairly decent that they wouldn't want mafia to know about.
Just state whether or not you have an item, but do use judgement. Don't claim an item if you're an important asset to the town.
"I do not wish to disclose" sounds more like someone has an item but isn't exactly stating it explicitly. This is kind of a giveaway and a silly idea. In most situations I have observed the items given out are probably better kept as a secret than revealed to everyone.
Fiestaguy
The man with 8 fingers.
Well "I wish not to disclose" is another thing for "I'm not telling" and i just included it since there are surely people who want to choose neither of the two >.>
Anyway. Scrap the third option then.
Anyway. Scrap the third option then.
My original idea was that if one or two people claimed with a fairly basic item such as a vest, it might reveal if the setup was heavily based around items. Fiesta, here, however, has blown it out of proportion and gone on an item hunt, wishing to reveal all items, which is a futile and dangerous prospect.
Except that this is entirely different to how you worded it.
I think that this topic needs to be dismissed, as the prospect is unlikely and the concept has turned into a complete sludgebucket of an idea.
Fiestaguy
The man with 8 fingers.
[article=Old_Man_Oak_63 -2014]I'm fully aware that the pirates don't know who each other is, my vote was more an incentive to be assured a response from Timdood. It was also a device to open up discussion so that people aren't inclined to no-lynch straight off. We have time, lets use it.[/article]
- Status