[GAME OVER] Formula Mafia

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Middle of the pgs 70-80 they read more frantic to me b/c of seeing a frame-up job from hip. Complaining about being seen as panicking also pinged me since it was hypocritical in context of D0.
but why does context of d0 make you think you might be too harsh on finding pg 70-80 as frantic/scummy?

It was a fake claim after all. Ergo someone having doubts makes sense.
why does it turning out to be a fake claim make boo's doubts make any more sense?

What's up with it?
i just dont get what it means

You're not confirmed scum. That is the point.
what point though im so CONFUSED
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
The difference between assuming and thinking something is likely is pretty minor. Try again.
are you sure

assuming is very different from thinking something is likely

honestly idk why youre being so hostile with me, its not my fault your role is scummy, you literally said yourself you dont disagree with my logic so??? why are you acting like im being unreasonable

i assumed nothing at all so stop acting like i did. try again.
 

Stranger from Myst Island

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Feb 24, 2019
Messages
1
Reaction score
518
How does a 3P claim make you more believable?
Because roles with a lot of nuts and bolts to them, so to speak, tend to be 3p.

Why not just commit to your role and arguing through it?
Because then id be arguing largely against people's feelings about my role rather than anything of substance. If you'd care to explain to me how to accomplish that I'm all ears.

this seems to say you think its benign in part because shes claiming a role someone already had so im confused?
She specifically claimed a weaker version of my/Mooglie's role, which by the nature of being weaker, is more believable to be town bc townies generally have weaker roles than mafia/3p.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Actually making my role sound fucking believable to the people who tend to either assume that having two people with any ability automatically means that one is scum.
also idk if this is about me or not but

if two messengers claimed id not think one is scum necessarily for example, its not that i dont think there can ever be two of the same ability for town

but two blockers does seem pretty town sided compared to most setups which is why i said it seemed unlikely
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Explain how I'm supposed to read this as anything other than an assumption.
by reading the words i used instead of imagining it to say "stranger's confirmed scum"?

saying "this sounds scummy" isnt "this is confirmed scum", its saying "this sounds scummy". idk how you think thats an assumption
 

Duffie

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,880
Reaction score
5,077
i mean why would it be OP
Likely as a chaos starter. Not very Townie, though.

Why would I frame you knowing that the race director could call me out anytime
To get the Race Director to out themselves, while, at the same time, pinning the broadcast on Boooo. Maybe this is reverse psychology, to get us to believe Boooo is a Townie, when in fact, she isn't?

Granted, we have a small enough reason to believe she is an Alignment Cop, that didn't investigate, but you wouldn't have known that during planning Night One.

to draw them out as a possible danger to yourself if they’re 3p

or race director is scum too

or ok maybe that point makes sense because i still townread stranger
I definitely think Stranger is Third Party, guven their role and goals, which also makes it seem as if Third Parties may be on a more even scale with Town? Unless it's just going to be difficult for her to win.

lol dess is reading the game

i bet hes seen the tag
I'M SO SORRY DESS

my money is on okx for making the message
Wait, where is this random FoS coming from? Any reasoning for Okx specifically? o 3o

Granted, looking at my chart, the odds are increasing for who it could be, out of everyone who hasn't claimed.

one thing i am confused about is the relevance of hips role
like if it doesnt intercept nightchat messages (or maybe it does since he said it was random) and theres only one day messaging role from what is tellable then is its 1 purpose to out this role's messages
does this mean the role is evil
if it is evil why send alisha such an irrelevant message rather than like 'you get dodgy vibes from car [number] [person]' to cause chaos
who knows!
I mean, if we have a Town Messager, wouldn't that mean Hip's claim would be Mafia or Third Party? I'd like to see a claim with some evidence or reasoning first, before even jumping on that.
 

MarsKid

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Oct 3, 2011
Messages
230
Reaction score
627
but why does context of d0 make you think you might be too harsh on finding pg 70-80 as frantic/scummy?
They called me out for being emotional and read deep into emotions D0, when those emotions were not there; I called them out and they seemed genuinely regretful of their behavior. So in context I could be committing the same mistake in reading/misreading their conduct.

why does it turning out to be a fake claim make boo's doubts make any more sense?
How would it not? If Boo didn't buy a claim, and the claim turned out to be fake, that means their reservations can be seen as valid. I don't understand why you're confused on this one.

i just dont get what it means
1. Don't believe Oog's read on you given what I've got from his posts.
2. Tim death was never a guarantee, which Oog has been adamant about.
3. Your scumread on Notty is fair b/c of Notty's style, and it is NAI.
4. Scum!Inf is more focused, town!Inf flails more. Current actions don't really point to scum!Inf.
5. Claim withholding is sketchy and Oog isn't off on calling this out.

The second part was re: Oog questioning my usage of misguided, which was clarified; earlier it seemed he thought us sharing a Notty tr meant Oog had to be town/not-misguided town in this scenario.

what point though im so CONFUSED
Point being that Oog was using Tim's death/the circumstances about it as proof of scum!Inf. If that were the case I would expect a greater push against you, and the only one holding the torch is Oog. There has been no bus to speak of.
 

Stranger from Myst Island

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Feb 24, 2019
Messages
1
Reaction score
518
saying "this sounds scummy" isnt "this is confirmed scum", its saying "this sounds scummy". idk how you think thats an assumption
The fact that you were willing to put a vote on me and encourage others to do the same, even through misremembered information (e.g. saying I had explicitly claimed town even though I hadn't done so) is very close to an assumption even if it wasnt quite there by your definition.
 

MarsKid

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Oct 3, 2011
Messages
230
Reaction score
627
Because roles with a lot of nuts and bolts to them, so to speak, tend to be 3p.
Town JOATs exist. And like I said, these role madness/closed set-up games leave room for craziness. It's almost an expectation.

Because then id be arguing largely against people's feelings about my role rather than anything of substance. If you'd care to explain to me how to accomplish that I'm all ears.
Sell it w/charisma, logic, break down the mechanics of the game. Could be difficult, fair, but claiming 3P doesn't help and could have turned you into a quick autolynch for scum to bail on.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
How would it not? If Boo didn't buy a claim, and the claim turned out to be fake, that means their reservations can be seen as valid. I don't understand why you're confused on this one.
thats not true though - if you found it unreasonable to doubt a 3p because town or scum don't benefit from claiming 3p, only 3p does, then stranger actually turning out to be town and boo being right shouldnt change that fact, so im confused as to where youre coming from

Point being that Oog was using Tim's death/the circumstances about it as proof of scum!Inf. If that were the case I would expect a greater push against you, and the only one holding the torch is Oog. There has been no bus to speak of.
why would me killing tim make me confirmed scum and thus warrant a bus from my team to look out for? or are you just argueing against the fact that im proven scum by saying if inf was proven scum his team would be bussing him?
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
The fact that you were willing to put a vote on me and encourage others to do the same, even through misremembered information (e.g. saying I had explicitly claimed town even though I hadn't done so) is very close to an assumption even if it wasnt quite there by your definition.
so are you saying every time somebody places a vote on someone and scumreads someone, they're "assuming" that person is scum?

do you only ever vote people who youre "assuming" to be scum then?

like i dont understand why you think i made an assumption, i didnt
 

Stranger from Myst Island

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Feb 24, 2019
Messages
1
Reaction score
518
Town JOATs exist. And like I said, these role madness/closed set-up games leave room for craziness. It's almost an expectation.



Sell it w/charisma, logic, break down the mechanics of the game. Could be difficult, fair, but claiming 3P doesn't help and could have turned you into a quick autolynch for scum to bail on.
I'm reading this as saying that these closer setups are inherently chaotic yet I should logic/analysis to defend myself in a setting that doesn't always conform to what people's expectations of a logical setup would be. Is that correct?
 

MarsKid

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Oct 3, 2011
Messages
230
Reaction score
627
thats not true though - if you found it unreasonable to doubt a 3p because town or scum don't benefit from claiming 3p, only 3p does, then stranger actually turning out to be town and boo being right shouldnt change that fact, so im confused as to where youre coming from
Because Stranger making a fakeclaim doesn't make me buy another claim from them. Boo not believing it makes sense because it turned out to be false and I don't see Stranger as town for making the fake; the town motivation isn't there FMPOV.

why would me killing tim make me confirmed scum and thus warrant a bus from my team to look out for? or are you just argueing against the fact that im proven scum by saying if inf was proven scum his team would be bussing him?
I am arguing against Tim death confirming you scum, b/c it doesn't add up.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Because Stranger making a fakeclaim doesn't make me buy another claim from them. Boo not believing it makes sense because it turned out to be false and I don't see Stranger as town for making the fake; the town motivation isn't there FMPOV.



I am arguing against Tim death confirming you scum, b/c it doesn't add up.
i still dont see how stranger turning out to be town suddenly means boo's argument makes sense to you

and i dont really get the argument about "tims death doesnt confirm inf as scum because his buddies arent bussing him" either; my teammates bussing me requires my teammates to think im confirmed scum, so thats irrelevant to whether oog thinks it makes me confirmed scum or not
 

MarsKid

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Oct 3, 2011
Messages
230
Reaction score
627
I'm reading this as saying that these closer setups are inherently chaotic yet I should logic/analysis to defend myself in a setting that doesn't always conform to what people's expectations of a logical setup would be. Is that correct?
Point being there is plenty of room for different roles; claiming your role as it was described is not inherently AI. The chaos means roles that are not typical are expected, and only by explaining those roles/putting them into context can the set-up start to make sense. You claim your role is inherently one that would be an autolynch when that's never guaranteed.

Claiming 3P does not solve anything here, or at the very least you have not elaborated on how it could solve anything; all it has done is make me doubt the claim and put other reads in a flux.
 

MarsKid

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Oct 3, 2011
Messages
230
Reaction score
627
i still dont see how stranger turning out to be town suddenly means boo's argument makes sense to you
You missed the part where I didn't buy Stranger as town.

and i dont really get the argument about "tims death doesnt confirm inf as scum because his buddies arent bussing him" either; my teammates bussing me requires my teammates to think im confirmed scum, so thats irrelevant to whether oog thinks it makes me confirmed scum or not
Except the argument was this: if Tim death = confirmed scum Inf, then massive push would happen = most likely a bus, but the opposite has happened and Oog is the only one making a push. This is going by the logic that Tim's death itself was enough of a 'writing on the wall' sign that a bus would be seen as viable by teammates.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
You missed the part where I didn't buy Stranger as town.
whys that relevant

you didnt think boo doubting stranger's 3p was reasonable, as you dont think doubting 3p claims makes sense

then stranger turned out to not be 3p and suddenly you think boo doubting is reasonable? that'd only work if you think boo had inside knowledge about stranger's true alignment

Except the argument was this: if Tim death = confirmed scum Inf, then massive push would happen = most likely a bus, but the opposite has happened and Oog is the only one making a push. This is going by the logic that Tim's death itself was enough of a 'writing on the wall' sign that a bus would be seen as viable by teammates.
ok, but i dont really get why this argument was necessary at all then? youre argueing against the fact that im globally considered to be confirmed scum, by saying people arent voting me?
 

MarsKid

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Oct 3, 2011
Messages
230
Reaction score
627
whys that relevant

you didnt think boo doubting stranger's 3p was reasonable, as you dont think doubting 3p claims makes sense

then stranger turned out to not be 3p and suddenly you think boo doubting is reasonable? that'd only work if you think boo had inside knowledge about stranger's true alignment
This assumes Boo isn't capable of making that read. Difficult, sure, but inside info isn't necessitated to make that happen.

ok, but i dont really get why this argument was necessary at all then? youre argueing against the fact that im globally considered to be confirmed scum, by saying people arent voting me?
Because Oog made this argument? This is getting excessive.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
This assumes Boo isn't capable of making that read. Difficult, sure, but inside info isn't necessitated to make that happen.
so are you saying

if someone reads x as scum for reason y, and you think reason y is ridiculous and doesnt make sense, BUT x then turns out to be scum, youd then find reason y to be reasonable? since that seems to be your argument which doesnt make sense right?

Because Oog made this argument? This is getting excessive.
oog never said i was globally scumread, hes not stupid, he'd know i wasnt by the fact i wasnt being lynched already
 

MarsKid

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Oct 3, 2011
Messages
230
Reaction score
627
so are you saying

if someone reads x as scum for reason y, and you think reason y is ridiculous and doesnt make sense, BUT x then turns out to be scum, youd then find reason y to be reasonable? since that seems to be your argument which doesnt make sense right?
You're assuming it inherently doesn't make sense when it could have been a misread, which happens. Basically this assumes there's never a world where Boo calls this out the fake.

oog never said i was globally scumread, hes not stupid, he'd know i wasnt by the fact i wasnt being lynched already
He seems convinced you are 100% scum. Do you not see this or do you choose to ignore it?
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
oog never said i was globally scumread, hes not stupid, he'd know i wasnt by the fact i wasnt being lynched already
(sorry if this comes off as aggressive btw i didnt mean for it to, im not implying youre stupid for argueing it, im just saying, oog would have to be stupid to think im globally scumread and he obv isnt stupid so i dont get why youre argueing with him about this as if you believe he thinks im globally scumread)
 
Top