General Quarters [Game Over]
- Thread starter Ltin
- Start date
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
I mean the mafia would have to have 6 people killed without any of them dying, so 3 consecutive day/night cycles of complete success, bearing in mind there's a doctor and a blocker and such. True we had a vigilante role but they would presumably only use that part of their role when the situation called for it and most of the time would use their watcher part. I dunno, we had a 14 player game with 4 mafia, seems fine to me to have a 16 player game with 5 mafia, especially since the third party role wasn't even harmful I don't think.
My false claim was basically your lasy way of proving you were town to me. I have thought you were mafia for a long time and by claiming you were mafia I would force we got more information. The circumstances made it unwise for a mafia to claim vanilla townie, which is one of the concerns I have with a normal "claim your role". My next post is about why I think you are mafia.Well that was very townie and helpful of you, not like you forced a PR to out ;-;
Then again I guess it's inevitable that you will die tomorrow and then there's no need to kill me since all I do is assist the cop so I guess it didn't do that much damage but still wow, I could have been more important
Who'd you investigate then? Why are you being so shady with your results I don't understand
My investigation was that Paige is town.
Also, Myuser I dont think it was a good idea to claim. Pretty sure infected would have gotten lynched anyway.
It is very useful for town to put the most suspicious person in a lot of pressure and make him claim after that. Basically, I just wanted to look at your reaction and claim, to give me your last chance to prove that you were town.
It is quite obvious that I will die next night and would like to say who I am suspicious of.
Here is what I think so far.
(he said this to me day 2 before I had claimed)
To be honest, it sounds like a very weak role, and will almost never be in use. If I am not mistaken your role only works if the cop, the lawyer and yourself hit the same person, or it is useless.
Other than that, I am not very suspicious of anyone else, but Arelic has brought me attention. I believe mainly this post but also in general that she seems to be on the same side as Infected.
Here is what I think so far.
Here is why I believe Myuser isnt lying about his role. He already a day ago said he had information about my role, which correcsponds with the role he got now. However, he can be lying, but I also feel like the role he has claimed isnt being made up.
(he said this to me day 2 before I had claimed)
If Myuser is town, it would mean that Infected is mafia. I always felt like Infected was very aggressive this game, and he tried to get several people which now have evidences of being townies lynched (me, Myuser, Notme, paig), while also being suspicious/sceptical to HKCaper and Mulb which also has evidences of being town. His role didnt make 100% sense to have in this setup. I do find it noteworthy that he tried to make his role fit in with events that theoretically could explain everything and that you are town.
To be honest, it sounds like a very weak role, and will almost never be in use. If I am not mistaken your role only works if the cop, the lawyer and yourself hit the same person, or it is useless.
Wait, what. I visited Mulb night 2, so how does you visiting Mulb night 1 explain that. Maybe you wanted to explain the incident with your role, but you couldnt since you were role blocked, but still you somehow did?
Also, this sounds weird to me too. You went against a person who the cop just claimed to be town and you knew were town, because you wanted to not look like you were a role that I cannot imagine mafias ever wanted to kill, or that they most likely wouldnt even know of.
Other than that, I am not very suspicious of anyone else, but Arelic has brought me attention. I believe mainly this post but also in general that she seems to be on the same side as Infected.
My gut feeling also says that Ender is town, and that JKangeroo is mafia. I also feel like Mulb is suspicious despite I have a town report from him. Not sure for Ooglie, but leaning towards town, maybe because I think Infected might be trying to make it look like they are a team.
G
Guest35486
Guest
This was Day 2, right after the department chats. Myuser posted questions for everyone to answer and this was my answer, though formatted a bit differently from the others. I listed reasons for all three of you because the first three questions were ranking how suspicious each of you were. (Which is why I put the "Not great with numbers" part first)
In the Operations chat, Inf had asked each of us for our suspicions. I was the first to bring up Unu due to his stating this: (Inf replied saying that he agreed)
Then he voted and unvoted for Notty rather quickly, claiming it was just for the bandwagon.
Inf summarized everyone's opinion in the chat in his massive post here: (both quotes are from the same post)
As it was only Day 2, your voting caught my attention. In my opinion, no one else was suspicious at the time. I don't think it's a good representation of my current thoughts and I would be glad to respond to any other posts you find suspicious. After all the new posts, I can say I've changed my opinion. I've been meaning to write a post about my take on the current claims, but putting them here may seem too defensive/desperate after Unu's post? I'll start on it soon anyway.
Well, after the incident happen first Mulb brought it up, then Infected and after that K1ng too (all in day 1). You were not first, and I believed at the time that it was suspicious that you brought up much of what Infected had said already.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
what about yourself? if you were there as well, do you have any opinions? and if not, why do you think fog would have anything more to say?
ignore if you already have said things about jk
Also, I suggest that we next day get all the 4 people (Arelic, Ender, Ooglie, JKangeroo) that we don't have evidence of being town to claim, to narrow down the mafia suspect list. I think that (with inf) most vanilla mafia roles are dead next day, and it will be a lot harder for mafias to claim. With myusers role I believe it would be risky for mafias to claim that they are vanilla roles, since myuser can visit them and find out, and if they claim an actual role we could decide if we believe it.
So, if Im not totally wrong about Myuser being town, I hope Arelic, Ender, JKangeroo and Ooglie will claim next day (dont claim now since mafias would get the info over night).
So, if Im not totally wrong about Myuser being town, I hope Arelic, Ender, JKangeroo and Ooglie will claim next day (dont claim now since mafias would get the info over night).
G
Guest35486
Guest
Sorry, I realize that wasn't clear. I meant first in the department chat, but I did forget Inf's post that you quoted. I see what you mean now, though if other people also share the same opinion, I'm not sure why I'm suspicious?
I was suspicious of all who shared that opinion, one who died and one who I got town report from.
Well I mean I found JKang the least suspicious in our group chat, however, I was suspicious of Notme and Paige going into the chat. I think if we kill Inf it would be positive either way because who cares about Inffy? Haha but I do think it would shift suspicion and help clear things up.
So I suppose
Double Vote Infected (because why not)
So I suppose
Double Vote Infected (because why not)
"You are one of them aren't you?"
"No, I am not!"
"Yes, you are!"
Enlisted 1st Class Infected_alien8_, a mutineer, has been lynched.
Infected_alien8_ was assigned to operations.
It is now Night 4. Please send in your actions.
"No, I am not!"
"Yes, you are!"
Enlisted 1st Class Infected_alien8_, a mutineer, has been lynched.
Infected_alien8_ was assigned to operations.
It is now Night 4. Please send in your actions.